The final stage of my Final Major Project involved bringing together the different sequences into a complete short animated film.
Watching The Observer as a continuous narrative allowed me to evaluate the relationship between the scenes rather than focusing on individual animations or technical elements.
My main objective was to explore emotional desensitisation through visual storytelling, without relying on spoken dialogue. The film contrasts the protagonist’s restrained reactions with the increasingly disturbing situations he encounters, eventually ending with his frustration when his phone runs out of battery.
I think the progression from everyday scrolling to increasingly distressing events helped establish the contrast between what the protagonist witnesses and how little he reacts. Returning to the bedroom at the end was particularly important, as it allowed me to contrast his earlier emotional detachment with his frustration over a relatively minor personal inconvenience.
I believe the final narrative communicates the contrast I originally wanted to explore, although I recognise that the audience may not necessarily interpret it in the same way.
When showing the film to my parents, who were not particularly familiar with the concept, they felt that the message was understandable. While this was encouraging, their reactions represent only limited informal feedback. A wider audience unfamiliar with the project would provide a better indication of whether the intended meaning is communicated effectively.
Watching the completed film also made certain limitations more noticeable, particularly in the animation quality and visual refinement of some sequences.
Although I feel that the overall narrative remains consistent with my original intentions, I recognise that the technical execution does not always achieve the cinematic quality I had envisioned.
6.2 Critical Reflection & Personal Development
Looking back at my Final Major Project, I have mixed feelings about the final outcome.
On one hand, I am proud of having produced a complete animated film, particularly considering that I had no previous experience with Maya or Unreal Engine before beginning my MA.
Developing my skills in Maya over approximately a year and a half has been one of my most significant achievements. I have gained a better understanding of the different stages involved in 3D production and how they contribute to a finished film.
On the other hand, I had higher expectations for the visual quality of my final result.
I tend to imagine projects on a much larger scale than I can realistically execute, and this became particularly evident during the production of The Observer.
Creative Ambition and Technical Execution
One of the clearest examples was the building collapse.
I originally envisioned a large-scale destruction sequence with dramatic explosions, environmental distortion and extensive visual effects.
Although I was pleased with what I managed to create, the final result was considerably more basic than my original references.
This was disappointing because I had imagined the collapse as one of the most visually impactful moments in the film. However, I also recognised the technical progress involved in producing the sequence.
The experience helped me understand that visual ambition needs to be supported by experimentation and a realistic assessment of production requirements.
Importantly, I do not feel that these technical compromises fundamentally weakened the narrative. My main dissatisfaction concerns the level of visual refinement rather than the underlying story.
Technical Problem-Solving
A significant part of my development during this project came from learning how to approach technical problems independently.
Throughout production, I regularly relied on online resources, tutorials and AI-assisted tools such as ChatGPT to investigate errors, explore possible solutions and understand unfamiliar techniques. My previous background in Digital Experience Design also helped me apply programming knowledge when working with Python scripts in Maya.
However, I realised that my approach to problem-solving was not always particularly structured.
When I encountered a problem, I often experimented with different solutions until I found something that worked. If an issue remained unresolved, I sometimes moved on temporarily, only to return to it later because I found it difficult to leave an imperfection unfinished.
While this persistence helped me overcome several technical obstacles, it also became one of the areas where I recognised a need for improvement.
I sometimes spent considerable time investigating details that had relatively little impact on the final film, rather than evaluating which problems were most important to resolve.
Looking back, I think one of the most valuable lessons was understanding the difference between being determined to solve a problem and approaching that problem efficiently.
In future projects, I would like to become more systematic in how I investigate technical issues, while also being more conscious of how individual decisions affect the wider production.
Evaluating My Animation and Visual Quality
When evaluating the visual quality of my final film, I recognise both areas of progress and aspects that could have benefited from further refinement.
I am particularly pleased with some of the more restrained character performances, especially the bedroom sequences, where small movements such as breathing, blinking and scrolling contribute to the protagonist’s detached behaviour.
The final angry expression also allowed me to establish a contrast between his earlier reactions and his frustration when the phone runs out of battery.
However, I recognise that animation polishing remains one of the weaker aspects of the film.
Certain walking movements required extensive adjustments, particularly when dealing with foot sliding and maintaining consistent character movement. Although I improved the animation, some issues remained, leading me to adjust the camera composition to reduce their visibility.
While this improved the presentation, it did not fully resolve the underlying animation problem.
I would also have liked to explore lighting in greater depth, particularly how it could contribute to atmosphere, visual depth and a more cinematic appearance.
These are areas I would like to continue developing, as I believe greater control over animation polishing and lighting would allow me to realise my future ideas more effectively.
Personal Development
Completing The Observer has changed how I approach the relationship between creative ambition and technical execution. I have realised that I often focus on the final visual result before fully considering the processes required to achieve it.
Rather than reducing my ambitions, I would like to develop a more experimental approach, testing unfamiliar techniques on a smaller scale before integrating them into larger productions.
The project has also reinforced what I enjoy most about 3D animation: the opportunity to transform an imagined concept into a complete film. Although I am not entirely satisfied with every aspect of the final result, I am proud of the skills I have developed and the fact that I was able to produce a short film of my own.