Categories
Final Major Project

04 — Production & Character Animation

4.1 Bedroom Animation

Establishing the Initial Performance

I began the character animation process with the bedroom sequence, which required a particularly restrained approach to movement.

Unlike the later city scenes, the bedroom animation focuses on ordinary actions such as lying down, breathing and scrolling through a phone.

Although these movements appear relatively simple, I found that small inconsistencies became noticeable because the character remains almost stationary for much of the sequence.

My initial focus was therefore on creating a believable resting position and determining which movements were necessary to prevent the character from appearing completely static.

I wanted his performance to feel natural without introducing gestures that would suggest stronger emotional reactions than intended.

Breathing and Subtle Body Movement

One of the first animations I developed was a breathing cycle.

I experimented with small vertical movements in the character’s upper body to suggest the gradual rise and fall associated with breathing.

Using the character’s spine controls in Maya, I adjusted the translation values across several keyframes to create a slow, repeated movement.

During testing, I noticed that larger movements made the character appear restless rather than relaxed.

I therefore reduced the amplitude and refined the timing to achieve a more subtle result.

I also experimented with movements in the shoulders and upper body to introduce additional naturalism. However, some of these adjustments created an exaggerated appearance or interfered with the character’s resting pose.

Rather than continuing to add movement, I decided to prioritise the breathing cycle and maintain a relatively stable body position.

This resulted in a more controlled performance that supported the quiet atmosphere of the opening sequence.

Phone Interaction

Another important aspect of the bedroom animation was the protagonist’s interaction with his phone.

Because scrolling plays a central role in the narrative, I wanted the movement to appear repetitive and almost automatic.

Designing the Social Media Feed

I began by designing a fictional social media feed in Figma.

I created an interface inspired by familiar social media layouts, deliberately alternating between content related to war and conflict and more ordinary posts, such as memes or general information.

This decision was influenced by my own experience of scrolling through social media, where disturbing news can appear directly alongside humorous or everyday content. I find this contrast particularly striking, as serious events can quickly become just another post to scroll past.

I wanted to reflect this experience in the film, showing how very different types of information are presented within the same continuous feed, potentially contributing to the normalisation of distressing events.

I then integrated the design into the 3D phone within my Maya scene.

Creating the interface myself allowed me to control not only its visual appearance but also the relationship between the content and the film’s central theme of emotional desensitisation.

The feed therefore became an important element of the visual storytelling, rather than simply a background detail on the protagonist’s phone.

Animating the Scrolling Movement

I animated a vertical scrolling gesture, experimenting with the timing and spacing of the keyframes.

Initially, the movement appeared too fast and mechanical, making it look more deliberate than I intended.

I adjusted the animation to create a slower and smoother gesture, reducing the amount of movement between keyframes.

This produced a more repetitive action that felt consistent with the protagonist’s detached behaviour.

Phone Lighting and Exposure

For the bedroom sequence, I wanted to create a dark, early-morning atmosphere, with the protagonist lying in bed while scrolling through his phone.

Since the room was intended to be almost completely dark, I wanted the phone screen to act as the main source of light, illuminating his face and making the interaction feel more natural.

To achieve this, I introduced an Arnold area light near the phone in Maya, positioning it so that the light would fall onto the character’s face.

I experimented with different exposure settings, including values of 7 and 8, to find a balance between making his facial features visible and maintaining the darkness of the room.

Some of the initial tests produced lighting that was too intense, making the environment appear brighter than I had intended. I therefore adjusted the exposure to achieve a more subtle effect.

This allowed me to maintain the quiet, intimate atmosphere of the bedroom while using the phone’s illumination to draw attention to the protagonist and his repetitive scrolling behaviour.

Reflection

The bedroom sequence demonstrated that restrained character animation can require considerable attention to detail.

I initially assumed that animating a character lying in bed would be relatively straightforward. However, creating convincing breathing and phone interactions required repeated adjustments to timing, spacing and controller values.

One of the most useful lessons was recognising that additional movement does not necessarily improve a performance.

By simplifying certain actions, I was able to maintain a more consistent character performance and direct attention towards the details most relevant to the narrative.

4.2 Facial Expressions & Emotional Performance

Developing the Character’s Expressions

After establishing the initial body animation, I began working more closely with the protagonist’s facial controls.

Since the character displays relatively few strong emotional reactions throughout the film, I needed to consider how small changes in expression could affect the audience’s interpretation.

Using the facial rig in Maya, I experimented with the eyebrows, eyes and mouth to understand how the different controllers influenced the character’s appearance.

I wanted to avoid an expression that appeared deliberately emotionless or exaggeratedly indifferent.

Instead, I aimed for a relatively neutral performance that could be interpreted through the relationship between the character and the surrounding events.

Blinking, Eye And Head Movement

Without any eye movement, the protagonist appeared unnaturally static, particularly in the closer bedroom shots.

I experimented with different blink timings and adjusted the movement to create a slower, slightly tired appearance.

I also tested changes in gaze direction and small head rotations. This involved some trial and error, as I needed to find a balance between making the movements appear natural and maintaining the character’s emotionally detached behaviour.

I eventually decided to animate the eyes moving first, followed by a subtle movement of the head in the same direction.

This was a deliberate creative decision. I wanted to communicate the idea that the protagonist notices what is happening around him but does not necessarily respond emotionally to it.

By allowing him to look towards something without introducing a stronger facial reaction, I hoped to reinforce the distinction between observing an event and emotionally engaging with it.

This approach also connects to the central theme of my film: emotional desensitisation does not necessarily mean that someone is unaware of what is happening, but rather that repeated exposure can influence how they respond to it.

Creating the Final Angry Expression

The final bedroom sequence required a different approach because it contains the protagonist’s most noticeable emotional reaction.

I wanted his frustration to contrast with the relatively neutral performance established throughout the earlier scenes.

I began by creating a neutral facial pose and then developed a more visibly angry expression.

Using the facial controllers, I adjusted the eyebrows to create tension around the eyes and modified the mouth controls to suggest frustration.

I experimented with the intensity of these changes because I wanted the emotion to remain recognisable without becoming excessively exaggerated.

The resulting transition creates a clear difference between the protagonist’s earlier expressions and his reaction to the phone running out of battery.

This was particularly important because the ending relies on facial animation to communicate the contrast at the centre of the narrative.

Technical Challenges with the Character Rig

Working with the facial rig also introduced several unexpected technical problems.

Eyes and Eyelashes

One recurring issue involved the character’s eyes and eyelashes, which did not always display or render correctly.

This was particularly noticeable in the closer bedroom shots, where small facial details became more apparent.

After investigating the character’s rig and geometry, I discovered that the eyeball was not properly connected to the character, which explained some of the problems I had encountered.

The eyelashes, however, proved considerably more difficult to fix. They appeared unusually large, and despite several attempts, I was unable to identify the exact cause.

I experimented with adjusting the geometry through face selection in Maya and investigated the material connections in Hypershade, but none produced the result I was looking for.

I eventually decided to leave the eyelashes as they were and continue with the rest of the animation.

Interestingly, when reviewing the final renders, I realised that the eyelashes were not nearly as distracting as I had initially thought.

Looking back, I think my tendency to focus on small imperfections led me to spend more time on this issue than its actual impact on the final film justified.

Although I would still have preferred to resolve it completely, this experience made me more aware of the difference between a technical detail that bothers me while working in Maya and one that genuinely affects the audience’s experience of the finished animation.

Hair Transparency and Opacity

One of the most frustrating technical challenges I encountered involved the protagonist’s hair.

Although I was using the same character model across different scenes, the hair did not render consistently. In some sequences, parts of the hair appeared as solid shapes rather than displaying the intended transparency.

What initially seemed like a relatively minor material issue turned into one of the most extensive troubleshooting processes of my project.

I began by investigating the hair material in Maya’s Hypershade, checking the opacity texture, transparency settings and shader connections. I also experimented with Arnold-specific attributes such as aiOpaque, as well as different texture and material settings.

When these adjustments did not resolve the issue, I started using Python scripts to inspect the hair mesh, identify its assigned materials and examine the connections between the texture files and shader attributes.

I became particularly focused on understanding why the same character appeared differently across my scenes. I therefore compared the material configurations between the bedroom and city environments to identify any inconsistencies.

Eventually, I discovered that the transparency settings differed between scenes. In the original bedroom scene, the transparency attribute displayed a white value, while in the later scenes it appeared black. I also identified a difference in the connected opacity nodes.

Although I attempted to restore the correct texture connections, the transparency issue persisted, and I was unable to achieve the same appearance across all scenes.

Looking back, this was probably the technical problem I became most determined to solve. Even after identifying differences between the shader connections in my scenes, I could not fully correct the hair transparency.

Although the investigation improved my understanding of shader networks, opacity maps and Maya’s material system, it also highlighted my tendency to become overly focused on small technical imperfections. I spent considerably more time on this issue than I had originally intended, which made me reconsider how I prioritised problems during production.

Neck Deformation

During one of my render tests, I noticed that the character’s neck had unexpectedly become deformed, creating an unnatural appearance that I had not noticed while working on the animation.

I was initially confused by the deformation, as the character had appeared normal during earlier stages of production.

After examining the affected area in Maya, I decided to correct the visible geometry directly. Using mesh component selection, I adjusted the affected faces to restore a more natural-looking neck shape.

I recognise that this was probably not the most technically appropriate solution, as I was correcting the appearance of the mesh rather than identifying and resolving the underlying rigging or deformation issue.

However, the adjustment improved the character’s appearance in the rendered shot and allowed me to continue working without the deformation remaining visually distracting.

Looking back, this was an example of how I sometimes approached technical problems through practical experimentation rather than following a conventional workflow. Although the solution worked visually, I recognise that understanding the underlying cause would have been more valuable for preventing similar issues in future animations.

Teeth Positioning

Another unexpected technical issue occurred while developing the protagonist’s final angry expression.

During one of my tests, I noticed that the character’s teeth had become displaced and were appearing outside his mouth, making the facial expression look unnatural.

I initially struggled to understand what had caused the problem, particularly because the teeth had been positioned correctly before I started adjusting the expression.

I investigated the teeth geometry in Maya, examined the associated skincluster and experimented with the controls responsible for their positioning.

After several attempts, I was able to restore the teeth to their original position and correct their appearance within the mouth.

Although this was a relatively small detail compared with the overall animation, it became particularly noticeable in the final close-up, where the character’s facial expression is the main focus.

This experience also made me more aware of how changes to individual elements of a character rig can produce unexpected results, even when the adjustments initially seem unrelated to the affected geometry.

Reflection

Developing the protagonist’s facial performance involved considerably more technical troubleshooting than I had initially anticipated.

Although the actual facial animation relied on relatively subtle movements, I encountered unexpected problems with the eyes, hair transparency, neck geometry and teeth positioning.

Some of these issues were resolved through adjustments to the rig or geometry, while others, particularly the hair transparency and eyelashes, remained imperfect despite extensive investigation.

Looking back, I recognise that I sometimes became more focused on correcting small technical details than evaluating how much they actually affected the final animation.

However, these experiences also encouraged me to explore Maya’s rigging and material systems in greater depth, developing a better understanding of how the technical structure of a character can influence its performance.

Despite these difficulties, I was able to create the contrast I wanted between the protagonist’s restrained expressions and his more noticeable frustration in the final sequence.

4.3 Walk Cycle Development

Creating the Initial Walk Cycle

One of the more technically challenging parts of my FMP was developing a convincing sad walk cycle for the protagonist.

Since a significant portion of the film takes place in an urban environment, the walking animation needed to remain natural and consistent across multiple shots.

I specifically wanted to create a slower, slightly withdrawn walking style, with restrained body movements that would reflect the protagonist’s emotionally detached state.

I began experimenting with the character’s body controls in Maya, focusing on the coordination between the legs, hips, arms and upper body.

Rather than creating an exaggerated sad performance, I wanted the character’s posture and movements to suggest a more subtle sense of tiredness and emotional distance.

Developing the Movement

During the initial animation process, I experimented with different cycle lengths and keyframe timings.

One of my earlier cycles used approximately 33 frames, while later experiments involved longer cycles to refine the movement.

I worked on coordinating the movements of the arms and legs while introducing subtle motion in the spine, chest and hips. I also considered how the character’s posture and the timing of his steps could contribute to the slightly withdrawn appearance I wanted.

I reviewed the foot contact positions, the transitions between poses and the relationship between the character’s upper- and lower-body movements.

This required several adjustments before the animation could be extended across longer sequences, particularly because even small inconsistencies became more noticeable when the same movement was repeated throughout the city shots.

Adjusting Walking Speed and Position

Another important challenge was coordinating the protagonist’s walk cycle with his forward movement through the city environment.

I used the character’s main controller in Maya to animate his translation along the street, while the individual body controllers were responsible for the walking movements.

During production, I experimented with different translation speeds, including approximately 3.49 Maya units per frame for certain sequences.

This involved considerable trial and error, as changing the forward speed could make the character appear to move too quickly or too slowly in relation to his steps.

As I continued refining the film, I also needed to extend several walking shots to improve their pacing. This meant adjusting the character’s movement over longer frame ranges while trying to maintain a consistent walking rhythm.

I found that simply extending the translation keyframes was not sufficient, as the distance travelled needed to remain coordinated with the timing of the walk cycle.

Even relatively small adjustments could introduce inconsistencies, particularly when the character’s feet were supposed to remain in contact with the ground.

I therefore repeatedly reviewed the animation and adjusted the movement to find a better balance between the walking speed, step timing and distance travelled.

This became one of the more time-consuming aspects of the walking animation, particularly because changes to the shot duration often required me to revisit movements that I had already adjusted.

Foot Sliding and Animation Refinement

One of the most persistent problems during the walk cycle development was foot sliding.

Although the overall movement sometimes appeared smooth, the character’s feet occasionally moved across the pavement during moments when they should have remained planted.

This became particularly noticeable after changing the walking speed or extending the animation.

Although adjusting the character’s walking speed helped reduce the foot sliding, it did not completely resolve the issue. Some sliding remained visible, particularly during moments when the feet were supposed to maintain contact with the ground.

After experimenting with different speeds and timing adjustments, I realised that these changes alone were not sufficient to achieve the result I wanted. I therefore decided to approach the problem from a cinematographic perspective by raising the camera angle, making the character’s feet less prominent within the composition.

While this did not technically eliminate the foot sliding, it made the remaining imperfections less noticeable in the final shot. This allowed me to improve the overall visual presentation without compromising the intended movement or narrative.

Looking back, I recognise that my understanding of walk cycles and root motion is still developing. Although I was not able to fully resolve the technical issue, the experience encouraged me to consider alternative solutions rather than focusing exclusively on the animation itself. It also demonstrated how cinematography and animation can work together to address visual challenges during production.

Geometry and Clothing Issues

During the walking animation, I also encountered problems with the character’s geometry.

At certain points, parts of the underlying body mesh became visible through the clothing, particularly around the trousers and upper legs.

This created distracting visual glitches that became more noticeable as the character moved.

To resolve this issue, I switched to Face Selection Mode in Maya and manually selected the affected faces of the trousers.

I then adjusted the position of these faces to create more space between the clothing and the underlying body mesh, preventing the character’s legs from clipping through the trousers.

I chose this approach because it allowed me to correct the problem directly on the clothing geometry without modifying the character’s body mesh or changing the existing walking animation.

After making these adjustments, I reviewed the character across different frames to check whether the trousers continued to cover the body correctly during movement.

This provided a targeted solution to the clipping issue while preserving the original character animation.

The experience demonstrated how clothing geometry can affect the visual quality of an animation, even when the character’s movements themselves are correct. It also highlighted the importance of checking mesh deformation throughout an animation rather than relying only on the character’s appearance in a static pose.

4.4 Secondary Characters & Background Animation

Creating Activity in the Urban Environment

Following the development of the protagonist’s walking animation, I began introducing secondary characters into the urban environment.

Their inclusion was important not only for creating a more convincing city atmosphere, but also for establishing the situations that the protagonist encounters throughout the narrative.

I wanted the environment to feel active and relatively ordinary, despite the increasingly disturbing events taking place within it. This contrast was central to my exploration of emotional desensitisation, as the protagonist’s limited reactions become more noticeable when placed against situations that would normally provoke an emotional response.

I therefore approached the placement and movement of secondary characters as part of the film’s visual storytelling rather than simply as background decoration.

Using Mixamo as a Production Strategy

One of the main considerations during this stage was how to balance the technical demands of character animation with the overall scope of the project.

Although I had developed my understanding of Maya and character animation throughout the course, I entered the programme without previous experience in 3D software. As a result, certain aspects of character animation remained technically challenging, particularly when working with multiple characters and more complex physical interactions.

The fight sequence was a particularly ambitious element of my original concept.

While I was interested in exploring this technically, I also had to evaluate whether the time required to animate the sequence independently would be justified by its role within the overall film.

The confrontation was not intended to become the central focus of the narrative. Its purpose was to establish a situation involving visible aggression, against which the protagonist’s emotional detachment could be observed.

I therefore decided to incorporate pre-existing animation resources from Adobe Mixamo for some of the secondary character movements.

This decision allowed me to approach the sequence more realistically while maintaining its intended narrative function.

Rather than treating Mixamo as a complete solution, I used the available animations as components within a larger production workflow. I still needed to consider their suitability, placement, timing and relationship to the camera composition.

It also allowed me to allocate more time to the elements that were particularly important to my film, including the protagonist’s performance, lighting, environmental composition and the relationship between the different sequences.

Looking back, this decision reflected an important aspect of managing an independent animation production: understanding where technical complexity meaningfully contributes to the narrative and where alternative approaches may be more appropriate.

Technical Challenges: Rig Compatibility Between Blender and Maya

Although using existing character assets initially appeared to offer a more manageable workflow, the integration process introduced several unexpected technical challenges.

One of the most significant involved a character rig that functioned correctly in Blender but did not behave as expected when transferred into Maya.

At first, I underestimated the difficulties associated with moving rigged characters between different 3D applications. I had assumed that if a character was already rigged, it would be relatively straightforward to use the same setup in another software environment.

However, I discovered that rigging systems are not always directly transferable, particularly when they rely on application-specific controls, constraints or animation setups.

While the character could be manipulated successfully in Blender, the same functionality was not preserved in Maya.

This created a problem because Maya was my primary animation and rendering environment, and I wanted to maintain a consistent workflow across the project.

I investigated different approaches to resolving the issue, experimenting with the available files and researching how character rigs and animation data could be transferred between applications.

However, identifying the exact cause proved difficult, particularly as my understanding of rig hierarchies and the technical structure of character animation was still developing.

The experience highlighted a distinction that I had not fully appreciated before: having access to a rigged character does not necessarily mean that the rig will be compatible with the intended production pipeline.

It also made me more aware of the importance of evaluating assets before integrating them into a project, rather than assuming that their existing functionality will be preserved across different software.

Ultimately, I had to reconsider whether continuing to troubleshoot this particular rig was an effective use of the remaining production time.

This contributed to my decision to explore a more manageable workflow using Mixamo and character assets that could be integrated more effectively into Maya.

Background Character Placement

I positioned additional characters across the urban environment, experimenting with their scale, orientation and distance from the camera.

I wanted to create a sense of depth by placing characters at different positions rather than distributing them across a single plane.

This also required considering how their movements would appear from the intended camera angles.

Characters positioned too close to the protagonist could distract from his performance, while those placed too far away might become difficult to recognise.

I therefore adjusted their positions to establish background activity while maintaining the readability of the main action.

Developing the Confrontation Sequence

One of the more challenging parts of introducing secondary characters was creating the confrontation between two background characters.

Since I was using pre-existing animations from Mixamo, my main task was integrating these movements into the Maya environment and ensuring that the characters appeared to interact convincingly.

I experimented with their positioning, orientation and timing to make the confrontation readable from the selected camera angle.

One of the main difficulties involved maintaining consistent contact with the ground. During certain movements, the characters appeared to float above the pavement or intersect with the surface.

I therefore experimented with adjusting their positions and keyframes to improve their alignment with the environment.

Although the animation itself was not created from scratch, integrating the movements still required several adjustments to make the sequence function within the composition of my film.

Placing the Cars

While developing the urban environment, I wanted the streets to feel more populated and believable.

The original city asset included a parking area containing several vehicles, which I decided to reuse throughout the environment rather than introducing additional external assets.

Using Face Selection Mode in Maya, I selected the geometry of individual cars and duplicated it so that I could reposition the vehicles across different streets.

After placing the cars, I also animated some of them to introduce movement into the environment.

I used translation keyframes to move the vehicles along the streets and adjusted the animation curves to create a constant, linear movement speed.

This was important because I wanted the cars to move consistently rather than gradually accelerating or slowing down between keyframes.

I experimented with their starting positions, movement distances and timing to make the traffic appear more natural within the camera compositions.

Although the vehicle animation was relatively simple, it helped make the city feel more active and contributed to the impression of an ordinary urban environment in which daily life continues around the protagonist.

Reflection

Working with secondary characters was more challenging than I initially expected, particularly because I had to manage multiple characters, imported animations and different rigging systems within the same environment.

Although using Mixamo reduced the amount of character animation I needed to create independently, integrating the existing movements into Maya still required adjustments to positioning, timing and ground contact.

The difficulties I encountered with transferring a rig from Blender to Maya also made me realise how important software compatibility is when selecting external assets.

Looking back, I think using pre-existing animations was an appropriate decision for this project. It allowed me to include the confrontation sequence without making it the main technical focus of my film, while still giving me experience working with multiple animated characters.

If I were to approach a similar project again, I would test the compatibility of character rigs and animations much earlier, before committing to them within the production.

4.5 Environmental Effects & Building Collapse

Developing the Destruction Sequence

One of the most visually ambitious sequences in my FMP involved the collapse of buildings within the city environment.

Unlike the earlier scenes, which focus primarily on character movement and interactions, this sequence introduces a large-scale environmental event.

I wanted the collapse to create a significant visual contrast with the protagonist’s relatively unchanged behaviour.

This required considering not only the movement of the buildings, but also how the event would appear within the camera composition.

Planning and Animating the Collapse

One of the biggest challenges when developing the building collapse was the size and complexity of the imported city environment.

The asset contained a large amount of geometry, making it difficult to isolate and manipulate individual buildings without affecting Maya’s performance.

Initially, I attempted to select and extract the necessary building geometry manually using Face Selection Mode. However, the scene was particularly heavy, and Maya repeatedly became unresponsive or crashed during these operations.

After several unsuccessful attempts, I began exploring Python scripting as an alternative way to manage the geometry.

My previous bachelor’s degree in Digital Experience Design (Design & Coding) had provided me with a foundation in programming, which helped me understand the logic behind using scripts to automate operations in Maya.

I used Python scripts to identify and extract the relevant mesh components, allowing me to separate the building geometry more efficiently than through manual selection alone.

Although I was familiar with programming concepts, applying them within Maya was a different experience. I needed to investigate how the software organised its geometry and how scripts could interact with the objects in the scene.

Once I had successfully separated the necessary geometry, I was able to animate the building independently from the surrounding environment.

I experimented with the building’s movement and timing, paying particular attention to how the collapse appeared from the selected camera angle.

Since the destruction takes place towards the right side of the frame, I wanted to ensure that the movement remained clearly visible and communicated the scale of the event.

Although the final collapse was considerably simpler than the large-scale destruction I had originally imagined, using scripting allowed me to overcome an obstacle that had initially prevented me from developing the sequence.

Considering Dust and Debris

Another important aspect was determining how the collapse would interact with the surrounding atmosphere.

I wanted the destruction to produce a substantial dust effect that could gradually spread across the composition.

However, creating this effect directly within the Maya environment introduced additional technical challenges.

I therefore began considering how the dust could be developed separately during post-production.

This decision allowed me to focus on the movement and framing of the collapse in Maya while exploring alternative methods for adding atmospheric effects later.

The development of the dust effect, including experiments in After Effects and Unreal Engine, is documented in the post-production chapter.

Reflection

The building collapse required me to consider animation on a much larger scale than the previous character-focused sequences.

One of the main challenges was balancing the visual impact of the destruction with the practical limitations of the environment and production workflow.

The process also demonstrated the importance of planning how different effects would eventually be combined.

Rather than attempting to create every element within a single application, I began separating the environmental animation from the atmospheric effects that could be developed during post-production.

4.6 Camera Animation & Cinematography

Establishing the Camera Compositions

As the animation developed, I began refining the camera movements and compositions across the different scenes.

Because my film relies on visual storytelling without dialogue, camera placement plays an important role in directing the audience’s attention.

I experimented with wide shots, medium shots and closer compositions depending on the information that needed to remain visible.

One of the main considerations was ensuring that the audience could observe both the protagonist and the events taking place around him.

This was particularly important in the city sequences, where the environment contains several animated elements.

Bedroom Camera Animation

For the opening bedroom sequence, I developed a slow camera movement towards the protagonist.

I wanted this movement to establish the setting gradually and give the audience time to observe his routine.

Initially, the camera movement was relatively short, but I later decided to extend it to create a more deliberate introduction.

During testing, I discovered that simply extending the frame range did not automatically continue the camera movement. The camera stopped at its original final keyframe rather than continuing at the same speed.

To resolve this, I adjusted the camera’s keyframes and animation curves, extending the movement while maintaining a consistent speed.

I also reviewed the camera animation across the entire shot to identify abrupt changes in movement and ensure that the protagonist remained correctly framed.

These adjustments allowed the camera to move more continuously and gave the opening sequence a slower, more controlled rhythm.

Alongside the wide shot, I experimented with medium shots and over-the-shoulder compositions.

The over-the-shoulder angle was particularly useful for showing the phone screen while keeping the protagonist visible within the frame.

Using these different compositions allowed me to alternate between establishing the bedroom environment and drawing attention to the character’s interaction with his phone.

Camera Composition in the City

The exterior scenes required different camera considerations because of the scale of the environment.

I experimented with positioning the cameras to establish depth and maintain visibility of the surrounding activity.

Wider compositions were useful for showing the relationship between the protagonist and the events taking place around him.

However, these shots also required careful placement of buildings, vehicles and background characters.

I made adjustments to the camera positions to avoid unwanted obstructions and improve the visibility of important actions.

The composition of the building collapse was especially important because the destruction needed to remain readable while taking place towards one side of the frame.

Shot Duration and Pacing

One of the more challenging aspects of the camera work was determining how long each shot should last.

During early tests, I discovered that some sequences progressed too quickly.

This was particularly noticeable when the audience needed time to recognise an event before the next shot began.

I therefore experimented with extending certain camera movements and animation sequences.

However, these changes often affected other animated elements within the scene.

For example, extending the duration of a walking shot required checking that the character’s movement continued correctly throughout the additional frames.

This demonstrated how closely camera timing and character animation were connected.

Reflection

Developing the cinematography helped me understand how camera movement can influence the rhythm and readability of an animated sequence.

I found that even simple camera movements required careful adjustment when their duration changed.

The process also demonstrated the importance of considering the relationship between animation, composition and editing rather than treating them as separate production stages.

4.7 Animation Challenges & Refinements

Revising an Unsuccessful Phone Interaction

During the development of the final bedroom sequence, I explored the possibility of having the protagonist throw his phone in frustration.

I wanted this action to create a more dramatic ending and make his emotional reaction immediately recognisable.

However, coordinating the movement of the phone with the character’s hand proved difficult.

I experimented with constraints and controller adjustments to make the phone follow the hand correctly.

Although I was able to position the phone for the interaction, the movement did not behave consistently throughout the animation.

The phone sometimes remained in place rather than following the intended motion.

I tested different approaches to correcting the interaction, but achieving a convincing throw introduced additional technical complexity.

Eventually, I decided to remove the action and focus on communicating frustration through the character’s facial expression.

This decision also influenced the creative direction of the ending.

Rather than relying on an exaggerated physical gesture, the final reaction became more restrained and focused on the contrast between the protagonist’s earlier behaviour and his visible frustration.

Although the phone-throw experiment was not included in the final animation, it was a valuable opportunity to explore object interaction, constraints and the relationship between technical feasibility and creative decision-making.

Using Python for Animation Adjustments

As the animation developed, I frequently needed to extend movements, adjust keyframes and modify existing animations to accommodate changes in shot duration.

Rather than performing every adjustment manually, I began using Python scripts within Maya to investigate animation data and automate certain operations.

For example, when extending the protagonist’s walking sequences, I used scripts to inspect the translation keyframes of the main controller and calculate additional positions based on the intended walking speed.

This allowed me to make more precise adjustments across longer frame ranges, although the results still needed to be checked visually to ensure that the movement remained consistent.

Working with scripts also required caution, as modifying the wrong controller or frame range could affect existing animation.

This approach allowed me to combine my previous programming knowledge with the animation techniques I was developing in Maya, particularly when dealing with repetitive adjustments that would otherwise require considerable manual work.

Scene Stability and Workflow Challenges

As the project developed, the increasing complexity of the Maya scenes also affected the production workflow.

Working with large environments, animated characters and multiple materials sometimes resulted in slower performance and unexpected software crashes.

This was particularly challenging when making adjustments to scenes that were approaching the rendering stage.

I became more cautious about modifying complex setups and increasingly aware of the importance of maintaining recoverable scene versions.

I also learned to check animation changes regularly rather than assuming that a modification would only affect the intended controller or frame range.

Reflection

The animation production stage required considerably more technical experimentation than I initially anticipated.

One of the most important developments was learning to approach animation problems more systematically.

Rather than repeatedly adjusting controls without understanding their behaviour, I became more comfortable inspecting keyframes, identifying relevant controllers and using Python scripts to investigate potential solutions.

I also learned that a technically complex animation is not necessarily more effective from a storytelling perspective.

Removing the unsuccessful phone-throw action was an example of how simplifying a movement could support the overall direction of the film.

These experiences helped me develop a more adaptable approach to animation production, balancing technical experimentation with the practical and creative requirements of the project.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *