Categories
Final Major Project

06 — Final Outcome, Evaluation & Reflection

6.1 Final Film & Presentation

The final stage of my Final Major Project focused on bringing the individual elements of production together into a complete short animated film.

After several stages of research, pre-production, animation, rendering and post-production, I began evaluating the project as a continuous narrative rather than a collection of individual shots.

The completed sequences follow the protagonist, The Observer, as he moves between his familiar bedroom environment and an increasingly disturbing urban setting.

One of my main objectives was to communicate emotional desensitisation without relying on spoken dialogue. Instead, I used character performance, visual contrast, camera composition and changes in the surrounding environment to communicate the narrative.

A particularly important element was the relationship between the severity of the events and the protagonist’s restrained reactions.

As the situations become more extreme, his behaviour remains relatively unchanged. This contrast is intended to make the audience question why certain events appear to have so little emotional impact on him.

The final bedroom sequence introduces a different response when the protagonist becomes frustrated after his phone runs out of battery.

I wanted this moment to challenge the expectations established throughout the film and emphasise the difference between his reactions to external suffering and a minor inconvenience affecting his personal routine.

Looking at the film as a whole also made me more aware of how individual creative and technical decisions affected the final narrative. Elements such as the duration of shots, the subtlety of facial expressions and the transition between environments became particularly important when evaluating whether the scenes worked together.

Although I cannot determine how every viewer will interpret the film without audience testing, I believe the final sequence provides a visual foundation for exploring the emotional contradiction at the centre of my research.

6.2 Critical Reflection & Personal Development

Looking back at my Final Major Project, I feel proud of what I have managed to achieve, particularly when considering my level of experience at the beginning of the course.

Before starting my MA in 3D Computer Animation, I had never worked with software such as Maya, Blender or Unreal Engine. Entering a completely unfamiliar field was challenging, especially because I tend to set very high expectations for myself and often have ideas that are more ambitious than my current technical abilities allow.

Throughout this project, one of my biggest challenges was accepting that the final result would not always match what I had originally imagined. I often had a very specific visual outcome in mind, but translating those ideas into three-dimensional animation required knowledge and experience that I was still developing.

This became particularly apparent during the more technically demanding sequences, such as the building collapse, environmental effects and certain character animations. Although I knew what I wanted these moments to look like, achieving that result was not always straightforward.

For example, when developing the building collapse sequence, I wanted the dust to gradually fill the environment and create a convincing transition between shots. I experimented with different approaches in After Effects and Unreal Engine, but achieving the density, depth and movement I imagined proved more complicated than expected. This made me realise how important it is to consider the technical requirements of an effect before incorporating it into a project.

However, I also recognise how much I have learned through these difficulties.

A significant part of my development came from independently researching solutions whenever I encountered a problem. I frequently consulted online tutorials, technical documentation, community discussions and AI-assisted tools such as ChatGPT to help me investigate unfamiliar techniques, understand errors and explore different approaches.

Rather than following a single established workflow, I often had to experiment, test possible solutions and adapt them to my own scenes. This was particularly important when working with complex character rigs, animation curves, Python scripts, lighting and rendering issues.

One example was the use of Python scripting in Maya. As my scenes became more complex, I began using scripts to inspect animation data, modify keyframes and extend character movements. This was particularly useful when adjusting the walking sequences, where maintaining consistent movement across different shots required repeated changes to controller positions and animation timing.

Although I did not always fully understand every technical issue immediately, working through these problems gradually made me more comfortable investigating how different parts of Maya functioned.

Another important lesson was understanding the relationship between creative ambition and technical feasibility.

I naturally tend to develop ambitious ideas, sometimes without fully considering how difficult they may be to execute. While I still consider this ambition an important part of my creativity, the project taught me that having a strong idea is only one part of the production process.

A clear example of this was the final bedroom sequence. I initially planned for the protagonist to throw his phone in frustration after discovering that the battery had died. However, creating a convincing interaction between the hand and the phone introduced several technical difficulties involving object constraints, positioning and animation.

After experimenting with different solutions, I eventually decided to remove the action and focus on communicating his frustration through facial animation instead.

Although this was not my original intention, it helped me understand that simplifying an idea does not necessarily mean losing its meaning. In this case, the more restrained reaction also remained consistent with the character’s overall performance.

I also became more aware of my own limitations as an animator. There are still aspects of the final film that I would like to improve, particularly the naturalness of certain character movements, the quality of the visual effects and the overall refinement of some sequences.

The walking animations, for example, required more adjustments than I had initially expected. Maintaining consistent movement while avoiding issues such as foot sliding or unnatural body positioning was particularly challenging.

These difficulties highlighted the importance of understanding body mechanics and movement rather than focusing only on achieving the correct position or timing.

I do not consider myself an advanced animator, and I know that I still have a great deal to learn. However, I also think it is important to recognise the progress I have made over a relatively short period.

Perhaps the most valuable lesson has been learning to balance my expectations with my experience. I still set high standards for myself, and I do not always feel completely satisfied when a result differs from what I originally imagined. However, I am beginning to understand that these differences are part of the learning process rather than simply signs of failure.

Ultimately, this project has helped me develop not only technical skills, but also greater patience, adaptability and confidence in my ability to learn unfamiliar tools.

While the final film may not fully reflect every detail of my original vision, it represents the knowledge, experimentation and problem-solving that I have developed throughout these past months. That is something I am genuinely proud of.

6.3 Future Improvements & Conclusion

Improving Pre-Production

If I were to approach a similar project again, one of the main changes I would make would be to develop a more detailed animatic before beginning character animation.

Although I created storyboards and planned the general sequence of events, I underestimated how much the timing of individual shots would influence the production process.

Several sequences needed to be extended after they had already been animated, which also required adjustments to character movement, camera animation and rendering.

For example, I extended the opening bedroom camera movement to give the audience more time to establish the environment and observe the protagonist’s routine.

Testing the full narrative earlier would have allowed me to identify these pacing problems before committing to more detailed production work.

Testing Technical Elements Earlier

Another improvement would be to test technically demanding elements before incorporating them into the main production.

The building collapse and dust effects demonstrated how a relatively short moment in the final film could require considerable experimentation.

In future projects, I would create smaller technical tests to determine whether an effect could be achieved with the available software, skills and production resources before developing the complete scene.

I would also establish a clearer system for saving scene versions and organising assets, particularly when working with large environments.

Developing My Animation and VFX Skills

From a technical perspective, I would like to continue developing my character animation skills, particularly in body mechanics, weight distribution and natural movement.

I would also like to explore facial animation and secondary movements in greater depth, as I became increasingly interested in how subtle changes in performance can communicate a character’s emotional state.

Another area I want to develop further is environmental effects and compositing. My experiments during this project introduced me to several techniques that I would like to understand more thoroughly, particularly the integration of atmospheric effects into three-dimensional scenes.

Incorporating Audience Feedback

Finally, I would introduce audience testing earlier in the development process.

Because The Observer relies on visual interpretation rather than spoken dialogue, feedback from viewers unfamiliar with my research would be particularly valuable.

I would be interested in understanding whether audiences recognise the contrast between the protagonist’s behaviour and his surroundings, and whether the final scene communicates the intended emotional contradiction.

This would allow me to evaluate the clarity of the narrative beyond my own interpretation.

Final Reflection

My Final Major Project has been an important opportunity to bring together the creative and technical skills I have developed throughout my MA in 3D Computer Animation.

What began as an investigation into emotional desensitisation developed into an independent production that challenged both my creative ambitions and technical abilities.

Although the process did not always progress as planned, it taught me that adapting an idea is just as important as developing it.

I still have many areas in which I want to improve, but completing this project has given me a better understanding of the animation production process and the skills required to translate an idea into a finished film.

Most importantly, it has shown me how much I can learn by challenging myself, experimenting with unfamiliar techniques and continuing to work through difficulties even when the outcome is uncertain.

Categories
Final Major Project

05 — Rendering, Visual Effects & Post-Production

5.1 Arnold Rendering & Optimisation

Establishing the Rendering Workflow

After completing the main animation and lighting setups, I began preparing the scenes for rendering using Arnold in Autodesk Maya.

My main objective was to achieve consistent image quality across the different shots while keeping rendering times manageable.

This was particularly important because the film combines two environments with different lighting conditions, materials and levels of complexity.

I wanted to maintain enough visual detail for the characters and environments to appear convincing without introducing unnecessarily long rendering times.

Render Settings and Sampling

During the initial rendering tests, I experimented with Arnold’s sampling settings to find an appropriate balance between image quality and performance.

I initially used a Camera AA value of 5 before increasing it to 8 for the higher-quality renders.

I made this adjustment because some of the initial results contained visible noise, particularly in areas involving shadows, indirect lighting and more complex materials.

Increasing the sampling value helped produce cleaner images, although it also increased the time required to render each frame.

I also experimented with diffuse sampling and denoising to investigate how these settings influenced the final appearance.

One of the main challenges was determining whether the improvement in visual quality justified the additional rendering time.

Rather than simply increasing every setting, I began comparing individual test renders to identify which adjustments produced noticeable improvements.

This helped me understand that higher sampling values do not automatically represent the most efficient rendering solution.

Rendering Image Sequences

I rendered the animation as individual PNG image sequences rather than exporting directly to video.

Although this decision had already been established during pre-production, it became particularly useful during the rendering stage.

Some sequences required a large number of frames, meaning that interruptions or rendering errors could become costly.

Using image sequences allowed me to inspect individual frames and continue rendering from a specific point when necessary.

It also made it easier to identify visual problems before importing the sequences into Adobe Premiere Pro.

This approach provided greater control over the rendered output and reduced the risk of having to repeat an entire sequence because of a problem affecting only a few frames.

Render Times and Performance

Rendering became one of the most time-consuming stages of the project.

During one rendering session, a sequence of approximately 220 frames required around four hours to complete.

This made me more aware of the practical consequences of increasing render quality, particularly when working with longer sequences.

Even relatively small changes to materials, lighting or camera movements could require additional rendering.

I therefore began treating render time as an important production consideration rather than something to evaluate only after completing the animation.

Before starting longer renders, I checked the camera framing, animation timing and lighting to reduce the likelihood of discovering major problems afterwards.

Although this did not eliminate every issue, it helped me approach the rendering process more carefully.

Testing and Quality Control

Before committing to complete image sequences, I used individual test renders to evaluate the appearance of different shots.

I checked lighting, shadows, material reflections, character visibility and overall composition.

This was especially important because certain assets appeared differently in Arnold compared with Maya’s viewport.

I also reviewed rendered frames to identify problems that might not have been obvious during animation.

One important consideration was ensuring that the visual quality remained consistent between the bedroom and exterior sequences despite their different lighting setups.

These tests helped me identify which elements required additional adjustments before committing to longer rendering sessions.

Reflection

Working with Arnold made me more aware of the relationship between visual quality, scene complexity and rendering efficiency.

The most useful lesson was learning to evaluate rendering settings according to their actual visual impact rather than assuming that higher values would always produce a better result.

This encouraged me to use test renders more deliberately and to consider the cost of making late changes.

As a result, rendering became an important part of my decision-making process rather than simply the final technical step after animation.

5.2 Materials & Texture Refinement

Working with Imported Materials

Throughout production, I encountered several inconsistencies in the materials and textures of imported 3D assets.

Because the environments and characters originated from different sources, their shaders did not always respond consistently to the lighting setups.

Some surfaces appeared excessively reflective, while others displayed incorrect colours or required adjustments to their transparency.

I used Maya’s Hypershade and Attribute Editor to investigate the relevant material properties and texture connections.

Rather than modifying the entire visual style of the scene, I focused on correcting individual assets that appeared noticeably inconsistent with their surroundings.

Adjusting Excessively Glossy Materials

One of the most noticeable issues involved the background characters and certain objects in the city environment.

Several imported materials appeared unusually glossy, creating strong reflections and highlights that did not suit the intended visual appearance.

This was particularly noticeable on some of the background characters, where clothing and body surfaces appeared almost plastic-like.

To investigate the problem, I examined the shader properties, including specular colour, reflectivity and related material settings.

I experimented with reducing unwanted reflections to create a more balanced appearance.

I also encountered similar problems with environmental objects, including streetlights, where certain surfaces remained reflective even after initial adjustments.

These issues required me to inspect the relevant materials individually rather than assuming that changing one setting would correct the entire object.

The adjustments helped reduce distracting highlights and improve the visual consistency of the exterior scenes.

Refining Traffic Light Materials

Another issue involved the traffic lights within the city environment.

Initially, some of the traffic light surfaces appeared almost black, even when they were intended to display an illuminated colour.

This made them difficult to recognise within the rendered scene.

I investigated the connected materials and experimented with emission settings to make the coloured surfaces more visible.

For example, I adjusted the green traffic light material to an emission value of approximately 5.

This made the illuminated section more recognisable without requiring additional external lighting.

I later experimented with similar adjustments for red traffic lights.

This was a relatively small modification compared with the larger animation tasks, but it improved the readability of the urban environment.

Maintaining Visual Consistency

As I continued testing materials, I realised that an object could appear acceptable in isolation but noticeably different when placed alongside other assets.

I therefore began evaluating materials within their actual lighting environments rather than relying entirely on the viewport.

This was particularly important for the city, where the combination of imported shaders and exterior lighting sometimes produced unexpected results.

Some material problems required repeated adjustments because changing the reflective properties of a surface could also influence its overall appearance.

I needed to find a balance between reducing unwanted highlights and preserving enough shading information for the objects to remain visually convincing.

Reflection

Refining the imported materials required more technical investigation than I initially expected.

Although the changes were often relatively small, they could noticeably affect the overall appearance of the rendered environment.

This process encouraged me to examine shader properties and texture connections more systematically instead of relying only on visual adjustments.

It also demonstrated that working with existing assets does not necessarily eliminate the need for material development and troubleshooting.

5.3 Compositing in After Effects

Exploring Dust and Atmospheric Effects

After developing the building collapse in Maya, I began investigating how to introduce dust into the sequence.

I wanted the collapse to feel larger and more destructive, with dust spreading across the environment and partially obscuring the scene.

One of my main concerns was achieving a convincing sense of volume and depth.

Because the building collapses towards the right side of the composition, I also wanted the dust to feel connected to that location rather than appearing as an unrelated effect covering the screen.

I initially explored compositing techniques in Adobe After Effects, using dust footage as a separate visual layer.

However, the first experiments did not fully produce the heavy, three-dimensional appearance I wanted.

Experimenting with Unreal Engine Niagara

To investigate an alternative approach, I experimented with Unreal Engine’s Niagara particle system.

I tested a dust explosion effect to explore whether a particle-based simulation could offer more control over the appearance and movement of the dust.

I experimented with the size and positioning of the effect and examined how the particles behaved within the 3D environment.

One difficulty involved positioning the simulation so that it appeared correctly from the intended camera angle.

Although the effect was visible, the results did not fully match the dense dust cloud I had imagined.

I also found that integrating a separate Unreal Engine effect into my existing Maya and After Effects workflow introduced additional complexity.

I therefore had to evaluate whether continuing to develop a complete particle simulation was practical within the remaining production time.

This experiment was useful because it allowed me to compare the flexibility of a particle-based system with the more accessible approach of compositing existing footage.

Evaluating External VFX Assets

Following the Niagara experiments, I began researching existing dust effects that could be adapted to the sequence.

I explored different stock footage and pre-made effects, comparing their density, direction and visual appearance.

One of the main difficulties was finding footage that matched the scale and movement of the building collapse.

Some effects appeared too light or transparent, while others moved in directions that did not correspond with the composition.

I was particularly interested in footage containing a dense cloud of dust that could gradually occupy a larger area of the frame.

Using existing footage offered a more manageable alternative to creating a complete particle simulation from scratch.

However, it also meant accepting certain limitations in perspective and the amount of control available over the movement.

Blending and Layer Integration

After importing dust footage into After Effects, I experimented with blending modes and layer settings to integrate it with the rendered animation.

Because the footage existed as a separate layer, I needed to consider how its background, colour and transparency interacted with the underlying scene.

I wanted to avoid an effect that looked obviously placed on top of the animation.

I therefore tested different blending approaches and examined how the dust appeared against the buildings and surrounding environment.

This helped me identify the limitations of the footage and determine which adjustments could improve its integration.

Adjusting Scale, Density and Movement

Another challenge was creating the impression of a sufficiently large dust cloud.

Some of the footage I tested appeared too transparent, particularly when placed over the exterior environment.

I experimented with increasing its scale and adjusting its visibility to create a heavier appearance.

However, enlarging the footage sometimes made the effect look flatter and less connected to the perspective of the scene.

I also explored directional movement because I wanted the dust to feel as though it originated from the collapsing buildings rather than expanding uniformly.

These experiments highlighted the difficulty of representing a three-dimensional atmospheric event through two-dimensional footage.

Experimenting with Timing and Transitions

As I continued developing the effect, I also explored how the dust could contribute to the transition between shots.

I experimented with reversing and extending the footage to change the direction and timing of its movement.

I also adjusted opacity to create a gradual fade rather than allowing the dust to disappear abruptly.

This was particularly important because the effect needed to remain connected to the timing of the building collapse.

I considered how the dust could temporarily obscure the environment before gradually disappearing or transitioning into the following sequence.

Although the experiments did not provide the same control as a complete 3D simulation, they allowed me to explore how compositing and editing could work together to create a more continuous visual sequence.

Reflection

The dust experiments became an important example of balancing visual ambition with technical feasibility.

I initially wanted a dense, three-dimensional effect, but creating and integrating this proved more complicated than expected.

Comparing After Effects, Niagara and existing VFX footage helped me evaluate the advantages and limitations of different approaches.

The main difficulty was not simply creating visible dust, but making the effect appear connected to the camera perspective, surrounding environment and timing of the collapse.

This process gave me a better understanding of how environmental effects need to be considered within the complete composition rather than developed in isolation.

5.4 Editing & Sound Design

Assembling the Film in Premiere Pro

After rendering the animated sequences, I began assembling the film in Adobe Premiere Pro.

I imported the PNG image sequences from Maya and arranged the different shots on the timeline.

One of the first technical issues I encountered involved the frame rate.

Although the animation was created at 24 frames per second, Premiere Pro initially interpreted some imported image sequences at 25 fps.

This created a potential inconsistency between the original animation timing and the editing timeline.

I therefore checked the footage interpretation and sequence settings to maintain a consistent frame rate of 24 fps.

This was important because even a small difference in playback speed could influence the timing of character movements and camera animation.

Refining the Pacing

One of the biggest challenges during editing was evaluating how the individual shots worked together.

While certain animations appeared effective when viewed separately in Maya, their timing sometimes felt different once they were assembled into a continuous sequence.

For example, some shots moved too quickly for the audience to observe both the protagonist and the surrounding events.

This was particularly important because the protagonist’s restrained reactions require time to become noticeable.

I therefore experimented with extending several sequences and adjusting the overall rhythm of the film.

In some cases, these changes required returning to Maya to extend camera movements or character animations before rendering additional frames.

Although this added work to the production process, it allowed me to make decisions based on how the film functioned as a complete narrative rather than judging each shot independently.

The editing process therefore became an important part of refining the animation itself.

Exploring Music and Atmosphere

Because the film contains no spoken dialogue, I also began exploring how music and sound could contribute to the emotional atmosphere.

I was particularly interested in using changes in sound intensity to support the progression of the narrative.

One idea involved gradually introducing a more chaotic soundscape as the protagonist encounters increasingly disturbing events in the city.

In contrast, I considered using a sudden change in atmosphere when the narrative returns to the bedroom.

I wanted the sound to reinforce the difference between the external environment and the protagonist’s personal routine without directly explaining his emotional state.

This required considering how music could support the visual storytelling rather than dominate it.

Sound Effects and Environmental Detail

I also explored how environmental sounds could help establish the different locations and events.

For the bedroom, I considered subtle ambient sounds that could reinforce the relatively quiet atmosphere.

The urban sequences offered opportunities to introduce traffic, pedestrian activity and other environmental sounds.

The confrontation and building collapse also presented opportunities for more intense audio.

I wanted to avoid creating a soundtrack that remained constantly loud or chaotic, as this could reduce the impact of the more dramatic moments.

Instead, I was interested in how changes in volume, intensity and silence could influence the audience’s experience.

In particular, the contrast between the destruction taking place outside and the protagonist’s ordinary routine offered an opportunity to use sound as an additional storytelling element.

Reflection

Editing the rendered sequences helped me identify pacing problems that were difficult to recognise while working on individual shots in Maya.

I realised that a technically successful animation does not automatically produce an effective sequence when placed alongside other shots.

The editing process required me to reconsider the duration of certain movements and how the audience’s attention shifted throughout the narrative.

It also encouraged me to treat sound as part of the film’s storytelling rather than simply as an additional element introduced after the visual work.

5.5 Final Rendering Challenges & Reflection

Managing Software Instability

One of the most significant challenges during the later stages of production was the instability of Autodesk Maya.

As the project became more complex, I experienced unexpected crashes and slower performance, particularly when working with detailed environments and demanding scene configurations.

This was frustrating because certain problems occurred while I was making adjustments to scenes that were already close to completion.

I also accessed Maya through Omnissa Horizon for parts of the production, meaning that my workflow depended on both the software and the stability of the remote connection.

This sometimes made it more difficult to work efficiently, particularly when switching between scene adjustments, animation and rendering tests.

As a result, I became more cautious about making major changes to complex scenes and placed greater importance on maintaining recoverable versions.

Managing Late-Stage Changes

Another challenge was deciding how to approach adjustments after sequences had already been rendered.

During editing, I continued identifying opportunities to improve shot timing, camera movement and visual consistency.

However, even relatively small changes could require additional rendering.

This meant considering whether a modification would produce a noticeable improvement or introduce unnecessary risks and production time.

I began prioritising adjustments that directly affected the readability and pacing of the film.

For example, extending a shot could be more important than refining a minor background detail if it allowed the audience to understand the narrative more clearly.

This required a different approach from the earlier stages of production, where I had more flexibility to experiment with individual elements.

File Management and Recovery

Managing project files also became increasingly important as production progressed.

Working with multiple Maya scenes, textures, imported assets and rendered image sequences resulted in a large number of files and different versions.

At one point, I encountered a situation where a Maya scene appeared to be missing.

Fortunately, I was able to recover the file, but the experience made me more aware of the importance of maintaining backups.

Working across different computers and using cloud synchronisation also required additional attention to file locations and accessibility.

I needed to ensure that the correct versions of scenes and supporting assets were available when continuing work.

This experience demonstrated how file management could directly influence production efficiency, particularly when dealing with large and technically demanding projects.

Learning to Prioritise

As the film approached completion, I became increasingly aware that not every technical or visual issue could receive the same amount of attention.

Throughout production, I had sometimes spent considerable time attempting to refine relatively minor details.

Although this helped me develop my technical skills, I also began recognising that some adjustments had a greater impact on the final film than others.

I therefore started evaluating changes according to their contribution to the narrative and overall visual quality.

This was especially important when deciding whether to repeat a render, extend an animation or continue experimenting with a visual effect.

Rather than attempting to perfect every individual element, I began focusing more on the consistency and effectiveness of the film as a whole.

Reflection

The final production stage required me to balance technical refinement with the practical limitations of completing an independent animated film.

One of the main lessons was learning to recognise when additional experimentation was useful and when it risked delaying more important work.

The combination of software instability, rendering requirements, file management and late-stage adjustments encouraged me to develop a more organised and selective approach to production.

Although not every visual or technical element reached the level of refinement I initially imagined, these experiences helped me understand the importance of making decisions within the context of the complete project.

The most valuable outcome was developing a more realistic understanding of how creative ambition, technical limitations and production time influence one another when bringing an animated film towards completion.

Categories
Final Major Project

04 — Production & Character Animation

4.1 Bedroom Animation

Establishing the Initial Performance

I began the character animation process with the bedroom sequence, which required a particularly restrained approach to movement.

Unlike the later city scenes, the bedroom animation focuses on ordinary actions such as lying down, breathing and scrolling through a phone.

Although these movements appear relatively simple, I found that small inconsistencies became noticeable because the character remains almost stationary for much of the sequence.

My initial focus was therefore on creating a believable resting position and determining which movements were necessary to prevent the character from appearing completely static.

I wanted his performance to feel natural without introducing gestures that would suggest stronger emotional reactions than intended.

Breathing and Subtle Body Movement

One of the first animations I developed was a breathing cycle.

I experimented with small vertical movements in the character’s upper body to suggest the gradual rise and fall associated with breathing.

Using the character’s spine controls in Maya, I adjusted the translation values across several keyframes to create a slow, repeated movement.

During testing, I noticed that larger movements made the character appear restless rather than relaxed.

I therefore reduced the amplitude and refined the timing to achieve a more subtle result.

I also experimented with movements in the shoulders and upper body to introduce additional naturalism. However, some of these adjustments created an exaggerated appearance or interfered with the character’s resting pose.

Rather than continuing to add movement, I decided to prioritise the breathing cycle and maintain a relatively stable body position.

This resulted in a more controlled performance that supported the quiet atmosphere of the opening sequence.

Phone Interaction

Another important aspect of the bedroom animation was the protagonist’s interaction with his phone.

Because scrolling plays a central role in the narrative, I wanted the movement to appear repetitive and almost automatic.

Designing the Social Media Feed

I began by designing a fictional social media feed in Figma.

I created an interface inspired by familiar social media layouts, incorporating content that could plausibly appear during everyday browsing.

I then integrated the design into the 3D phone within my Maya scene.

I chose to create the interface myself because I wanted greater control over its appearance and how it contributed to the visual storytelling.

The feed helped establish the phone as an important narrative element rather than simply an object held by the protagonist.

Animating the Scrolling Movement

I animated a vertical scrolling gesture, experimenting with the timing and spacing of the keyframes.

Initially, the movement appeared too fast and mechanical, making it look more deliberate than I intended.

I adjusted the animation to create a slower and smoother gesture, reducing the amount of movement between keyframes.

This produced a more repetitive action that felt consistent with the protagonist’s detached behaviour.

Phone Lighting and Exposure

To simulate the light emitted by the phone screen, I introduced an Arnold area light near the device.

I experimented with different exposure settings, including values of 7 and 8, to control how strongly the light illuminated the character’s face.

Some of the initial tests produced lighting that was too intense and distracted from the subdued bedroom atmosphere.

I therefore experimented with reducing the exposure and removing additional exposure adjustments to achieve a more balanced result.

This process showed me how lighting could contribute to making an animated interaction more convincing, while also influencing the emotional atmosphere of the scene.

Refining the Animation

As the sequence developed, I repeatedly reviewed the animation in Maya to evaluate its timing and smoothness.

Some movements that initially appeared acceptable became too noticeable when viewed alongside the other elements of the scene.

I therefore adjusted or removed unnecessary actions and experimented with extending certain shots to give the audience more time to observe the protagonist.

This was particularly important because the sequence relies on small changes in movement rather than dramatic physical actions.

Reflection

The bedroom sequence demonstrated that restrained character animation can require considerable attention to detail.

I initially assumed that animating a character lying in bed would be relatively straightforward. However, creating convincing breathing and phone interactions required repeated adjustments to timing, spacing and controller values.

One of the most useful lessons was recognising that additional movement does not necessarily improve a performance.

By simplifying certain actions, I was able to maintain a more consistent character performance and direct attention towards the details most relevant to the narrative.

4.2 Facial Expressions & Emotional Performance

Developing the Character’s Expressions

After establishing the initial body animation, I began working more closely with the protagonist’s facial controls.

Since the character displays relatively few strong emotional reactions throughout the film, I needed to consider how small changes in expression could affect the audience’s interpretation.

Using the facial rig in Maya, I experimented with the eyebrows, eyes and mouth to understand how the different controllers influenced the character’s appearance.

I wanted to avoid an expression that appeared deliberately emotionless or exaggeratedly indifferent.

Instead, I aimed for a relatively neutral performance that could be interpreted through the relationship between the character and the surrounding events.

Experimenting with Blinking and Eye Movement

One of the first aspects I developed was the character’s blinking.

Without any eye movement, the protagonist appeared unnaturally static, particularly in the closer bedroom shots.

I experimented with different blink timings and adjusted the movement to create a slower, slightly tired appearance.

I also tested changes in gaze direction and small head rotations.

However, some of these movements made the character appear more alert or reactive than intended.

After reviewing the animation, I decided to remove several of the additional head and eye movements while retaining the slower blinking.

This allowed the character to maintain a more restrained expression without appearing completely frozen.

Creating the Final Angry Expression

The final bedroom sequence required a different approach because it contains the protagonist’s most noticeable emotional reaction.

I wanted his frustration to contrast with the relatively neutral performance established throughout the earlier scenes.

I began by creating a neutral facial pose and then developed a more visibly angry expression.

Using the facial controllers, I adjusted the eyebrows to create tension around the eyes and modified the mouth controls to suggest frustration.

I experimented with the intensity of these changes because I wanted the emotion to remain recognisable without becoming excessively exaggerated.

The resulting transition creates a clear difference between the protagonist’s earlier expressions and his reaction to the phone running out of battery.

This was particularly important because the ending relies on facial animation to communicate the contrast at the centre of the narrative.

Technical Challenges with the Character Rig

Working with the facial rig also introduced several unexpected technical problems.

Eyes and Eyelashes

One recurring issue involved the character’s eyes and eyelashes, which did not always display or render correctly.

This affected the appearance of the character in closer shots, where the facial details were particularly noticeable.

I investigated the relevant geometry, visibility settings and materials to identify possible causes.

These problems demonstrated how issues unrelated to the keyframe animation itself could still affect the quality of a character’s performance.

Hair Transparency and Opacity

Another challenge involved the character’s hair.

Although I was using the same character model across different scenes, the appearance of the hair was not always consistent.

I investigated the connected opacity texture and examined the material’s transparency settings.

I also checked Arnold-specific attributes, including aiOpaque, which affects how transparency is handled during rendering.

By comparing the material configurations between scenes, I was able to identify differences that influenced the appearance of the hair.

This required several tests involving shader connections, texture settings and render attributes.

Neck Deformation

At one point, the character’s neck unexpectedly became deformed, creating an unnatural appearance.

I investigated the rig controls and geometry to determine which transformations were affecting the character’s proportions.

This was particularly frustrating because the issue appeared while I was already developing the character’s performance.

Correcting the deformation required checking the relationship between the rig and the visible character mesh rather than simply adjusting the facial animation.

Teeth Positioning

Another significant issue occurred while developing the final angry expression.

The character’s teeth became displaced and appeared outside the mouth, affecting the appearance of the expression.

I investigated the teeth geometry, the associated skinCluster and the controls responsible for their positioning.

After experimenting with these settings, I restored the teeth to their correct position.

This was particularly important because the final expression needed to remain visually convincing in a relatively close camera composition.

Reflection

Developing the facial animation required me to work with both the creative and technical aspects of character performance.

While the animation itself involved relatively small movements, the rig introduced problems involving geometry, deformation, materials and visibility.

I learned that creating a convincing expression depends not only on the positioning of facial controllers, but also on maintaining the technical consistency of the character model.

The final angry expression was especially important because it allowed me to create a noticeable emotional contrast without introducing an entirely new action or sequence.

4.3 Walk Cycle Development

Creating the Initial Walk Cycle

One of the more technically challenging parts of my FMP was developing a convincing walk cycle for the protagonist.

Since a significant portion of the film takes place in an urban environment, the walking animation needed to remain natural and consistent across multiple shots.

I began experimenting with the character’s body controls in Maya, focusing on the coordination between the legs, hips, arms and upper body.

I also used an online animation tutorial as a learning reference to better understand the timing and structure of a walk cycle.

However, adapting these principles to my own character and scene requirements involved additional experimentation.

Developing the Movement

During the initial animation process, I experimented with different cycle lengths and keyframe timings.

One of my earlier cycles used approximately 33 frames, while later experiments involved longer cycles to refine the movement.

I worked on coordinating the movements of the arms and legs while introducing subtle motion in the spine, chest and hips.

One of the main difficulties was creating a cycle that could repeat continuously without producing noticeable changes in rhythm.

I therefore reviewed the contact positions, the transitions between poses and the relationship between the character’s upper- and lower-body movements.

This required several adjustments before the animation could be extended across longer sequences.

Creating a Continuous Loop

Once the basic walk cycle was established, I needed to repeat the movement across longer sections of the film.

Rather than manually duplicating every keyframe, I experimented with Maya’s animation curves and cycle infinity settings.

This allowed certain movements, particularly those involving the arms and upper body, to continue repeating beyond their original keyframe ranges.

However, I discovered that repeating a cycle did not automatically produce a seamless result.

Differences between the beginning and end of the animation could still create sudden changes in movement.

I therefore reviewed the loop transitions and adjusted the animation curves where necessary.

Using cycle infinity reduced the amount of repetitive keyframe work and made it easier to maintain a consistent movement pattern over longer durations.

Adjusting Walking Speed and Position

Another important challenge was coordinating the walk cycle with the character’s movement through the city.

I used the main character controller to animate his forward translation along the street.

During production, I experimented with different translation speeds, including approximately 3.49 Maya units per frame for certain sequences.

As I extended and adjusted the duration of individual shots, I also needed to update the character’s movement.

This required checking that the distance travelled remained consistent with the timing of the walk cycle.

I found that even relatively small adjustments to the forward translation could affect how naturally the feet interacted with the ground.

Maintaining consistency across different shots therefore required more than simply extending the character’s position keys.

Foot Sliding and Animation Refinement

One of the most persistent problems during the walk cycle development was foot sliding.

Although the overall movement sometimes appeared smooth, the character’s feet occasionally moved across the pavement during moments when they should have remained planted.

This became particularly noticeable after changing the walking speed or extending the animation.

Although adjusting the character’s walking speed helped reduce the foot sliding, it did not completely resolve the issue. Some sliding remained visible, particularly during moments when the feet were supposed to maintain contact with the ground.

After experimenting with different speeds and timing adjustments, I realised that these changes alone were not sufficient to achieve the result I wanted. I therefore decided to approach the problem from a cinematographic perspective by raising the camera angle, making the character’s feet less prominent within the composition.

While this did not technically eliminate the foot sliding, it made the remaining imperfections less noticeable in the final shot. This allowed me to improve the overall visual presentation without compromising the intended movement or narrative.

Looking back, I recognise that my understanding of walk cycles and root motion is still developing. Although I was not able to fully resolve the technical issue, the experience encouraged me to consider alternative solutions rather than focusing exclusively on the animation itself. It also demonstrated how cinematography and animation can work together to address visual challenges during production.

Geometry and Clothing Issues

During the walking animation, I also encountered problems with the character’s geometry.

At certain points, parts of the underlying body mesh became visible through the clothing, particularly around the trousers and upper legs.

This created distracting visual glitches that became more noticeable as the character moved.

To resolve this issue, I switched to Face Selection Mode in Maya and manually selected the affected faces of the trousers.

I then adjusted the position of these faces to create more space between the clothing and the underlying body mesh, preventing the character’s legs from clipping through the trousers.

I chose this approach because it allowed me to correct the problem directly on the clothing geometry without modifying the character’s body mesh or changing the existing walking animation.

After making these adjustments, I reviewed the character across different frames to check whether the trousers continued to cover the body correctly during movement.

This provided a targeted solution to the clipping issue while preserving the original character animation.

The experience demonstrated how clothing geometry can affect the visual quality of an animation, even when the character’s movements themselves are correct. It also highlighted the importance of checking mesh deformation throughout an animation rather than relying only on the character’s appearance in a static pose.

Reflection

Developing the walk cycle was one of the most technically demanding animation tasks in the project.

I initially underestimated how difficult it would be to maintain consistent walking movement across shots with different durations and positions.

The process required repeated experimentation with timing, animation curves, forward translation and foot contact.

Although not every issue was fully eliminated, these experiments helped me become more confident in diagnosing movement problems and understanding how different animation controls interact.

The techniques I developed also made it easier to reuse and adapt the walk cycle as the film evolved.

4.4 Secondary Characters & Background Animation

Creating Activity in the Urban Environment

Following the development of the protagonist’s walking animation, I began introducing secondary characters into the urban environment.

Their inclusion was important not only for creating a more convincing city atmosphere, but also for establishing the situations that the protagonist encounters throughout the narrative.

I wanted the environment to feel active and relatively ordinary, despite the increasingly disturbing events taking place within it. This contrast was central to my exploration of emotional desensitisation, as the protagonist’s limited reactions become more noticeable when placed against situations that would normally provoke an emotional response.

I therefore approached the placement and movement of secondary characters as part of the film’s visual storytelling rather than simply as background decoration.

Using Mixamo as a Production Strategy

One of the main considerations during this stage was how to balance the technical demands of character animation with the overall scope of the project.

Although I had developed my understanding of Maya and character animation throughout the course, I entered the programme without previous experience in 3D software. As a result, certain aspects of character animation remained technically challenging, particularly when working with multiple characters and more complex physical interactions.

The fight sequence was a particularly ambitious element of my original concept.

While I was interested in exploring this technically, I also had to evaluate whether the time required to animate the sequence independently would be justified by its role within the overall film.

The confrontation was not intended to become the central focus of the narrative. Its purpose was to establish a situation involving visible aggression, against which the protagonist’s emotional detachment could be observed.

I therefore decided to incorporate pre-existing animation resources from Adobe Mixamo for some of the secondary character movements.

This decision allowed me to approach the sequence more realistically while maintaining its intended narrative function.

Rather than treating Mixamo as a complete solution, I used the available animations as components within a larger production workflow. I still needed to consider their suitability, placement, timing and relationship to the camera composition.

It also allowed me to allocate more time to the elements that were particularly important to my film, including the protagonist’s performance, lighting, environmental composition and the relationship between the different sequences.

Looking back, this decision reflected an important aspect of managing an independent animation production: understanding where technical complexity meaningfully contributes to the narrative and where alternative approaches may be more appropriate.

Technical Challenges: Rig Compatibility Between Blender and Maya

Although using existing character assets initially appeared to offer a more manageable workflow, the integration process introduced several unexpected technical challenges.

One of the most significant involved a character rig that functioned correctly in Blender but did not behave as expected when transferred into Maya.

At first, I underestimated the difficulties associated with moving rigged characters between different 3D applications. I had assumed that if a character was already rigged, it would be relatively straightforward to use the same setup in another software environment.

However, I discovered that rigging systems are not always directly transferable, particularly when they rely on application-specific controls, constraints or animation setups.

While the character could be manipulated successfully in Blender, the same functionality was not preserved in Maya.

This created a problem because Maya was my primary animation and rendering environment, and I wanted to maintain a consistent workflow across the project.

I investigated different approaches to resolving the issue, experimenting with the available files and researching how character rigs and animation data could be transferred between applications.

However, identifying the exact cause proved difficult, particularly as my understanding of rig hierarchies and the technical structure of character animation was still developing.

The experience highlighted a distinction that I had not fully appreciated before: having access to a rigged character does not necessarily mean that the rig will be compatible with the intended production pipeline.

It also made me more aware of the importance of evaluating assets before integrating them into a project, rather than assuming that their existing functionality will be preserved across different software.

Ultimately, I had to reconsider whether continuing to troubleshoot this particular rig was an effective use of the remaining production time.

This contributed to my decision to explore a more manageable workflow using Mixamo and character assets that could be integrated more effectively into Maya.

Reflection on Creative Ambition and Technical Scope

Working with secondary characters became an important part of evaluating my approach to production.

Throughout the project, I frequently found myself developing ideas that were more ambitious than what I could immediately achieve with my current technical knowledge.

The fight sequence was a clear example of this. In my initial planning, I focused primarily on the visual outcome I wanted to achieve, without fully considering the technical complexity involved in producing a convincing interaction between multiple characters.

As production progressed, I became more aware of the difference between conceptual development and the practical demands of animation.

This required me to make decisions about which elements deserved the greatest amount of technical attention and which could be approached through alternative methods.

I do not consider the use of Mixamo to be a replacement for developing my own animation skills. Instead, it became a way of managing the demands of the project while continuing to develop those skills through the animation work I completed independently.

At the same time, the difficulties I experienced with the Blender rig and the integration of imported animations revealed gaps in my technical understanding, particularly regarding rig compatibility and character animation pipelines.

If I were to approach a similar project again, I would evaluate potential character assets and their compatibility with my chosen software much earlier in pre-production. I would also carry out smaller animation and import tests before committing to a particular rig or workflow.

This could reduce the amount of time spent resolving unexpected technical issues during production and provide a more reliable foundation for complex scenes.

I would also consider the complexity of character interactions earlier when developing the storyboard, allowing the narrative and technical production requirements to inform one another more effectively.

Overall, this stage of the project helped me understand that the successful execution of an animated film depends not only on individual technical skills, but also on the ability to evaluate production methods, adapt to unexpected challenges and make informed decisions.

Although some of the results differed from what I had originally imagined, the process encouraged me to become more resourceful and critical in how I approached animation production.

Most importantly, it reinforced the idea that technical decisions should ultimately support the intention of the film. In this case, the purpose of the secondary characters was not to demonstrate complex animation for its own sake, but to establish the emotional and narrative context in which the protagonist’s desensitisation becomes visible.

Background Character Placement

I positioned additional characters across the urban environment, experimenting with their scale, orientation and distance from the camera.

I wanted to create a sense of depth by placing characters at different positions rather than distributing them across a single plane.

This also required considering how their movements would appear from the intended camera angles.

Characters positioned too close to the protagonist could distract from his performance, while those placed too far away might become difficult to recognise.

I therefore adjusted their positions to establish background activity while maintaining the readability of the main action.

Developing the Confrontation Sequence

One of the more complex interactions involved a confrontation between two background characters.

Unlike the protagonist’s restrained movements, this sequence required more noticeable physical action.

I worked on positioning the characters within the environment and coordinating their movements so that the interaction remained understandable from the camera’s perspective.

A particular challenge was maintaining consistent contact with the ground.

During certain movements, the characters appeared to float above the pavement or intersect with the surface.

I experimented with positional adjustments and keyframes to improve their alignment with the ground.

This was important because even small inconsistencies became noticeable during more energetic movements.

Animation Timing and Coordination

Managing several animated characters within the same environment introduced additional challenges.

I needed to consider when each action began, how long it continued and whether the movements remained visible within the camera frame.

As the timing of individual shots changed, I also needed to adjust some of the background animations.

I repeatedly reviewed the scenes to identify movements that appeared unnatural or interfered with the main action.

This required balancing the activity of the environment with the visual importance of the protagonist.

Reflection

Working with secondary characters required a different approach from animating the protagonist.

While the main character’s performance depended on subtle timing and restrained movements, the background characters required greater attention to placement, coordination and interaction with the environment.

The confrontation sequence was particularly useful for developing my understanding of ground contact and the timing of multiple character movements within the same shot.

4.5 Environmental Effects & Building Collapse

Developing the Destruction Sequence

One of the most visually ambitious sequences in my FMP involved the collapse of buildings within the city environment.

Unlike the earlier scenes, which focus primarily on character movement and interactions, this sequence introduces a large-scale environmental event.

I wanted the collapse to create a significant visual contrast with the protagonist’s relatively unchanged behaviour.

This required considering not only the movement of the buildings, but also how the event would appear within the camera composition.

Planning and Animating the Collapse

The building collapse takes place towards the right side of the frame, meaning that the direction and visibility of the movement were particularly important.

One of the biggest technical challenges was working with the size and complexity of the imported city asset. The environment contained a large amount of geometry, which made it difficult to manipulate individual buildings without affecting Maya’s performance.

Initially, I attempted to separate the building geometry manually so that I could animate the collapse independently from the rest of the environment. However, selecting and extracting the relevant mesh components repeatedly caused Maya to become unresponsive or crash.

To overcome this limitation, I decided to use Python scripting within Maya rather than continuing to separate the geometry manually.

Using a script allowed me to automate parts of the mesh extraction process and work more selectively with the geometry required for the collapse.

My previous academic background in Digital Experience Design had provided me with a foundation in programming and computational problem-solving. Although I had limited experience applying these skills within a 3D production environment, I was already familiar with coding principles and the logic behind automation.

This influenced my approach to technical challenges in Maya. Rather than relying entirely on manual operations, I recognised that scripting could offer a more efficient way of managing repetitive tasks and complex scene structures.

I chose this approach because it reduced the need for repetitive manual operations on a particularly heavy scene and provided a more manageable way of preparing the building for animation.

It also allowed me to transfer knowledge from my previous studies into a different creative and technical context. While 3D animation was still relatively new to me, this experience demonstrated how my existing programming knowledge could support my developing animation workflow.

Once the necessary geometry was separated, I could work on the building’s movement independently from the surrounding city environment.

I then focused on how the collapse appeared from the selected camera angle, adjusting the movement to ensure that the destruction remained clearly visible towards the right side of the composition.

This approach allowed me to continue developing the sequence despite the limitations of the original asset.

It also demonstrated how scripting could be used not only for animation adjustments, but also for scene preparation and managing complex geometry.

Rather than being limited by the performance of the imported asset, I was able to adapt my workflow and find an alternative method for achieving the intended visual effect.

Considering Dust and Debris

Another important aspect was determining how the collapse would interact with the surrounding atmosphere.

I wanted the destruction to produce a substantial dust effect that could gradually spread across the composition.

However, creating this effect directly within the Maya environment introduced additional technical challenges.

I therefore began considering how the dust could be developed separately during post-production.

This decision allowed me to focus on the movement and framing of the collapse in Maya while exploring alternative methods for adding atmospheric effects later.

The development of the dust effect, including experiments in After Effects and Unreal Engine, is documented in the post-production chapter.

Reflection

The building collapse required me to consider animation on a much larger scale than the previous character-focused sequences.

One of the main challenges was balancing the visual impact of the destruction with the practical limitations of the environment and production workflow.

The process also demonstrated the importance of planning how different effects would eventually be combined.

Rather than attempting to create every element within a single application, I began separating the environmental animation from the atmospheric effects that could be developed during post-production.

4.6 Camera Animation & Cinematography

Establishing the Camera Compositions

As the animation developed, I began refining the camera movements and compositions across the different scenes.

Because my film relies on visual storytelling without dialogue, camera placement plays an important role in directing the audience’s attention.

I experimented with wide shots, medium shots and closer compositions depending on the information that needed to remain visible.

One of the main considerations was ensuring that the audience could observe both the protagonist and the events taking place around him.

This was particularly important in the city sequences, where the environment contains several animated elements.

Bedroom Camera Animation

For the opening bedroom sequence, I developed a slow camera movement towards the protagonist.

I wanted this movement to establish the setting gradually and give the audience time to observe his routine.

Initially, the camera movement was relatively short, but I later decided to extend it to create a more deliberate introduction.

During testing, I discovered that simply extending the frame range did not automatically continue the camera movement. The camera stopped at its original final keyframe rather than continuing at the same speed.

To resolve this, I adjusted the camera’s keyframes and animation curves, extending the movement while maintaining a consistent speed.

I also reviewed the camera animation across the entire shot to identify abrupt changes in movement and ensure that the protagonist remained correctly framed.

These adjustments allowed the camera to move more continuously and gave the opening sequence a slower, more controlled rhythm.

Alongside the wide shot, I experimented with medium shots and over-the-shoulder compositions.

The over-the-shoulder angle was particularly useful for showing the phone screen while keeping the protagonist visible within the frame.

Using these different compositions allowed me to alternate between establishing the bedroom environment and drawing attention to the character’s interaction with his phone.

Camera Composition in the City

The exterior scenes required different camera considerations because of the scale of the environment.

I experimented with positioning the cameras to establish depth and maintain visibility of the surrounding activity.

Wider compositions were useful for showing the relationship between the protagonist and the events taking place around him.

However, these shots also required careful placement of buildings, vehicles and background characters.

I made adjustments to the camera positions to avoid unwanted obstructions and improve the visibility of important actions.

The composition of the building collapse was especially important because the destruction needed to remain readable while taking place towards one side of the frame.

Shot Duration and Pacing

One of the more challenging aspects of the camera work was determining how long each shot should last.

During early tests, I discovered that some sequences progressed too quickly.

This was particularly noticeable when the audience needed time to recognise an event before the next shot began.

I therefore experimented with extending certain camera movements and animation sequences.

However, these changes often affected other animated elements within the scene.

For example, extending the duration of a walking shot required checking that the character’s movement continued correctly throughout the additional frames.

This demonstrated how closely camera timing and character animation were connected.

Reflection

Developing the cinematography helped me understand how camera movement can influence the rhythm and readability of an animated sequence.

I found that even simple camera movements required careful adjustment when their duration changed.

The process also demonstrated the importance of considering the relationship between animation, composition and editing rather than treating them as separate production stages.

4.7 Animation Challenges & Refinements

Managing Animation Across Multiple Shots

As production progressed, managing the animation across different shots became increasingly challenging.

Although individual actions could work correctly in isolation, changes to camera timing or shot duration often required adjustments to several animated elements.

I frequently needed to extend existing movements, shift keyframes or remove animations that were no longer required.

These tasks became more complicated as the scenes accumulated additional controllers and animation curves.

I therefore began exploring ways to make the process more efficient and precise.

Using Python Scripts for Animation Adjustments

One of the most useful technical developments during production was incorporating Python scripts into my Maya workflow.

As the animation became more complex, I frequently needed to extend movements, adjust frame ranges and modify existing keyframes. Performing these operations manually could be time-consuming, particularly when working with multiple controllers.

I therefore began using Python scripts to inspect animation data and automate certain repetitive adjustments.

One example involved extending the protagonist’s walking animation after changing the duration of a city shot.

I used scripts to examine the existing translation keyframes of the main controller and calculate additional positions based on the intended walking speed.

This allowed me to continue the character’s forward movement without manually positioning every additional keyframe.

However, scripting also introduced challenges. Applying changes to the wrong controller or frame range could produce unexpected movements or affect existing animation.

I therefore learned to inspect the relevant controllers and keyframes before making modifications and to review the animation afterwards.

Although the scripts improved the efficiency of certain tasks, they did not eliminate the need for visual evaluation. I still needed to check whether the movement remained consistent with the walk cycle and whether issues such as foot sliding had been introduced.

This approach allowed me to combine procedural adjustments with traditional keyframe animation, making it easier to adapt existing sequences as the film developed.

Rig and Controller Issues

Another challenge involved understanding how different controllers interacted within the character rigs.

In some cases, modifying one controller did not produce the movement I expected.

I also encountered situations where animation values appeared to reset or movements behaved inconsistently across different frames.

To investigate these problems, I examined controller attributes, keyframe data and the relationships between different parts of the rig.

This was particularly useful when working with movements that involved multiple body controls.

These experiences helped me develop a more systematic approach to troubleshooting animation issues rather than relying entirely on visual trial and error.

Revising an Unsuccessful Phone Interaction

During the development of the final bedroom sequence, I explored the possibility of having the protagonist throw his phone in frustration.

I wanted this action to create a more dramatic ending and make his emotional reaction immediately recognisable.

However, coordinating the movement of the phone with the character’s hand proved difficult.

I experimented with constraints and controller adjustments to make the phone follow the hand correctly.

Although I was able to position the phone for the interaction, the movement did not behave consistently throughout the animation.

The phone sometimes remained in place rather than following the intended motion.

I tested different approaches to correcting the interaction, but achieving a convincing throw introduced additional technical complexity.

Eventually, I decided to remove the action and focus on communicating frustration through the character’s facial expression.

This decision also influenced the creative direction of the ending.

Rather than relying on an exaggerated physical gesture, the final reaction became more restrained and focused on the contrast between the protagonist’s earlier behaviour and his visible frustration.

Although the phone-throw experiment was not included in the final animation, it was a valuable opportunity to explore object interaction, constraints and the relationship between technical feasibility and creative decision-making.

Scene Stability and Workflow Challenges

As the project developed, the increasing complexity of the Maya scenes also affected the production workflow.

Working with large environments, animated characters and multiple materials sometimes resulted in slower performance and unexpected software crashes.

This was particularly challenging when making adjustments to scenes that were approaching the rendering stage.

I became more cautious about modifying complex setups and increasingly aware of the importance of maintaining recoverable scene versions.

I also learned to check animation changes regularly rather than assuming that a modification would only affect the intended controller or frame range.

The more detailed challenges involving rendering performance, Arnold and file management are discussed in the following chapter.

Reflection

The animation production stage required considerably more technical experimentation than I initially anticipated.

One of the most important developments was learning to approach animation problems more systematically.

Rather than repeatedly adjusting controls without understanding their behaviour, I became more comfortable inspecting keyframes, identifying relevant controllers and using Python scripts to investigate potential solutions.

I also learned that a technically complex animation is not necessarily more effective from a storytelling perspective.

Removing the unsuccessful phone-throw action was an example of how simplifying a movement could support the overall direction of the film.

These experiences helped me develop a more adaptable approach to animation production, balancing technical experimentation with the practical and creative requirements of the project.

Categories
Final Major Project

03 — Pre-Production & Visual Development

3.1 Storyboarding & Shot Planning

Developing the Storyboard

Once the narrative structure had been established, I began translating the concept into a sequence of visual shots.

I created a storyboard to explore the composition, character positioning and progression of the different scenes. Since my film contains no spoken dialogue, I wanted to ensure that the audience could understand the sequence of events through visual information alone.

Rather than focusing on detailed illustrations, I used relatively simple sketches to establish the main compositions and camera angles.

This allowed me to concentrate on how the events would be presented and how the protagonist would be positioned in relation to his surroundings.

I experimented with different shot types, including wide shots, medium shots and closer compositions.

For the bedroom sequence, I wanted to establish a familiar and relatively quiet atmosphere, allowing the audience to observe the protagonist’s routine before introducing more intense events.

For the city sequences, wider compositions were particularly important because they allowed the surrounding environment and background activity to remain visible alongside the protagonist.

This was essential to the concept, as the contrast between the character’s behaviour and the events around him depends on the audience being able to observe both simultaneously.

The storyboard therefore helped me identify which moments required more emphasis on character performance and which could communicate their meaning primarily through composition and environmental changes.

Shot Planning & Timing

After establishing the main compositions, I began considering the approximate duration and rhythm of each sequence.

One of my initial intentions was to create a relatively slow opening, allowing the audience to become familiar with the protagonist’s ordinary routine.

As the film progresses into the city, the situations become increasingly intense, creating a contrast between the progression of external events and the character’s restrained behaviour.

However, I realised that the effectiveness of this approach would depend heavily on timing.

If the shots were too short, the audience might not have enough time to recognise the events or observe the protagonist’s lack of reaction.

On the other hand, holding every shot for too long could affect the overall rhythm of the film.

I therefore treated the storyboard as an initial guide rather than establishing fixed durations for every sequence.

This gave me flexibility to reconsider the timing once the scenes were assembled and animated in Maya.

Reflection

Developing the storyboard helped me translate an abstract concept into a more practical visual structure.

One of the most useful outcomes was identifying how camera composition could support the narrative without requiring additional character movements or dialogue.

It also helped me recognise that the effectiveness of the film would depend not only on the events themselves, but on how long the audience was given to observe them.

Although the storyboard provided a foundation for production, I expected the compositions and timing to evolve as I began testing the scenes in 3D.

3.2 Character Selection & Development

Selecting the Main Character

For my FMP, I decided to work with an existing rigged 3D character rather than modelling and rigging a character entirely from scratch.

I made this decision because the main focus of my project is character animation and visual storytelling.

Creating a character from the beginning would require additional time for modelling, texturing and rigging, potentially reducing the time available for developing the actual performances.

After exploring the possibilities, I selected a stylised character rig called Cartoon Young Boy, which became the protagonist of my film, The Observer.

I chose this character because his relatively simple appearance suited the visual direction I wanted to achieve.

Although stylised, the character has recognisable human proportions and facial features, allowing him to communicate emotions through relatively subtle changes in expression.

This was particularly important because I did not want the protagonist to appear overly expressive throughout the film.

I wanted his emotional state to remain somewhat ambiguous, allowing the audience to interpret his behaviour through the situations surrounding him.

Planning the Character’s Performance

Before beginning the animation, I considered which movements would be most important for communicating the protagonist’s behaviour.

Unlike a character who expresses emotions through exaggerated gestures, The Observer requires a more restrained performance.

I therefore decided to focus on small movements such as blinking, breathing, head positioning and changes in facial expression.

These movements are particularly relevant in the bedroom sequences, where the protagonist spends much of his time lying down and interacting with his phone.

I also considered how the character’s performance would change throughout the film.

While most of his reactions remain minimal, the final sequence introduces a more noticeable expression of frustration.

This contrast required the character rig to support both subtle movements and more recognisable facial expressions.

Planning these differences early helped me identify the animation controls that would become important during production.

Preparing the Character in Maya

After selecting the rig, I imported it into Autodesk Maya and began exploring its control system.

I examined the available facial and body controllers to understand how they influenced the character’s movements.

Particular attention was given to the eyes, head, shoulders, arms and facial controls, as these would be important for the planned performances.

I also began examining the character’s materials and textures to ensure that the model could be integrated into the different environments.

This preparation was useful because it allowed me to identify potential limitations before beginning more detailed animation work.

Although using an existing rig reduced the amount of modelling and rigging required, I still needed to become familiar with its structure and understand how to manipulate it effectively.

Reflection

Selecting an existing character rig allowed me to dedicate more attention to the aspects of animation most relevant to my project.

It also introduced an important technical learning opportunity, as I needed to understand a rig that I had not developed myself.

The preparation stage helped me establish which controllers were most useful for the planned performances and provided a foundation for the more detailed animation work documented in the production chapter.

3.3 Environment Design

Developing the Environments

For my FMP, I needed two principal environments: an interior bedroom and an exterior urban setting.

Although both environments belong to the same narrative, they serve different purposes.

The bedroom represents familiarity, comfort and repetitive everyday behaviour, while the city provides a setting in which the protagonist encounters increasingly distressing situations.

I wanted this contrast to be reflected not only through the events taking place, but also through the composition, scale and atmosphere of each environment.

Rather than modelling every object from scratch, I decided to work with existing 3D assets and adapt them to the requirements of my film.

This allowed me to focus more on environment composition, character placement, animation and lighting.

However, working with pre-existing assets still required making decisions about which elements were relevant to the narrative and how they should be presented.

Bedroom Environment

For the bedroom, I wanted to create a space that felt ordinary and recognisable.

I focused on arranging the furniture and positioning the protagonist in a way that would clearly communicate his everyday routine.

Since the bedroom appears at both the beginning and the end of the film, I also needed to consider how the environment would function across multiple camera angles.

I experimented with wider compositions to establish the room and closer shots to emphasise the protagonist’s interaction with his phone.

The placement of the bed and surrounding objects was particularly important because the character remains relatively stationary throughout much of these sequences.

I wanted the environment to provide enough visual detail to feel believable without distracting from his subtle movements.

Another consideration was how external lighting could influence the atmosphere of the room.

By allowing coloured emergency lights to enter from outside, I could suggest that significant events were happening beyond the bedroom without directly showing them.

This helped establish the contrast between the protagonist’s familiar private environment and the more disturbing world outside.

The bedroom therefore functions as more than a background. It provides a visual representation of the routine and comfort that remain central to the narrative.

Urban Environment

The city environment presented a different set of requirements.

I worked with a large existing urban asset containing buildings, streets, vehicles and other environmental elements.

Unlike the bedroom, the city needed to communicate a sense of scale and activity while allowing several events to take place across different shots.

One of the main challenges was deciding how much of the environment was actually necessary.

The original asset contained considerably more geometry than I needed for my planned sequences.

I therefore began identifying the streets and surrounding areas that would be most useful for the camera compositions and character movements.

I wanted the city to feel populated and believable, but I also needed to avoid unnecessary visual complexity.

The placement of background characters and environmental objects became important for creating depth and establishing activity.

At the same time, I needed to ensure that these elements did not distract from the events that the audience was intended to observe.

This was particularly relevant to the scenes involving homelessness, confrontation and the later building collapse.

By adapting an existing environment rather than building a complete city from scratch, I could dedicate more time to establishing the compositions and integrating the animated characters.

Asset Preparation and Technical Considerations

Working with assets from different sources required additional preparation.

Some imported models needed adjustments to their materials, textures and organisation before they could be used effectively in Maya.

The scale of the urban environment also introduced performance considerations, as large amounts of geometry could affect the responsiveness of the viewport and increase rendering requirements.

During this stage, I began organising the environment into more manageable scene setups and identifying which elements required further adjustments.

I also considered how the different assets would respond to lighting, particularly because the bedroom and city required different atmospheric conditions.

These preparations helped establish a more manageable working environment before moving into detailed animation and rendering.

Reflection

Developing the environments made me realise that environment design involves more than selecting visually appropriate assets.

I needed to consider how each space contributes to the narrative, how the camera would interact with its geometry and how much detail was necessary for the intended shots.

Using existing assets allowed me to focus on composition and storytelling, but it also introduced technical limitations that influenced the production workflow.

The most important outcome of this stage was establishing two contrasting environments that could support the protagonist’s behaviour and the progression of the narrative.

3.4 Visual Style & Lighting

Establishing the Visual Style

During pre-production, I began exploring how lighting, colour and atmosphere could support the psychological themes of my film.

Because the environments and characters came from different sources, I wanted to establish a visual style that would make them feel consistent within the same animated world.

I aimed for a stylised but recognisable aesthetic, combining relatively realistic environments with a simplified character design.

Rather than using highly dramatic lighting throughout the entire film, I wanted the atmosphere to develop through the contrast between the different locations.

The bedroom required a more subdued and intimate appearance, while the exterior scenes needed lighting that could clearly reveal the larger environment and its events.

Bedroom Lighting

For the bedroom sequences, I wanted to create an atmosphere that felt familiar and relatively calm while introducing subtle visual elements that suggested something unsettling.

I experimented with the placement, colour and intensity of several light sources to maintain visibility without making the room appear excessively bright.

One decorative element I incorporated was a lava lamp.

I chose to include it because it contributed to the familiar, personal atmosphere of the room, while introducing a soft coloured glow into the environment.

This provided a small source of visual interest without requiring additional movement from the protagonist.

Another important element was the use of red and blue emergency lights coming from outside.

I created separate light sources in Maya and experimented with animating their intensity to simulate flashing police lights.

I wanted these lights to suggest that something serious might be happening nearby, even though the protagonist continues following his usual routine.

This created an opportunity to communicate external activity through lighting rather than introducing another visible event or character into the scene.

During testing, I discovered that the placement and intensity of the lights affected how clearly the coloured flashes appeared.

The surrounding geometry also influenced their visibility, requiring me to reconsider the positioning of the light sources.

These experiments helped me establish a bedroom atmosphere that combines ordinary domestic details with subtle indications of disturbance.

City Lighting

For the exterior environment, I wanted to establish a lighting setup that would maintain visibility across the different city sequences.

I created a directional light named FMP_SUNLIGHT to simulate sunlight across the urban setting.

I experimented with its rotation, intensity and colour to understand how the lighting affected buildings, streets and characters.

I chose a slightly warm colour to give the environment a natural appearance while maintaining a consistent lighting direction across the different shots.

Using a directional light also allowed me to illuminate the larger environment without having to place separate lights around every object.

However, the scale and complexity of the city meant that I also needed to consider how shadows and imported materials responded to the lighting.

These early tests helped identify which elements would require further refinement before final rendering.

Reflection

Experimenting with lighting helped me understand how atmosphere could contribute to the narrative without relying entirely on character animation.

The subdued bedroom lighting, lava lamp and flashing emergency lights allowed me to establish a contrast between the protagonist’s private routine and the implied activity outside.

In comparison, the exterior lighting was designed to maintain clarity and visual consistency across the larger city environment.

This stage also demonstrated that lighting decisions could reveal technical issues with materials and geometry, making early testing an important part of the production process.

3.5 Technical Planning & Production Workflow

Software and Production Pipeline

Before beginning the main production stage, I established a workflow for managing the different elements of the animated film.

I selected Autodesk Maya as my primary software for scene assembly, character animation, camera positioning and lighting.

Since I had already developed experience with Maya throughout my MA, I wanted to build on that knowledge while becoming more confident with its animation and technical tools.

For rendering, I chose Arnold, which is integrated into Maya.

This allowed me to work with the lighting and material setups directly within the same environment used for animation.

I also planned to use Adobe After Effects for post-production, particularly for atmospheric effects associated with the building collapse.

For the final editing stage, I selected Adobe Premiere Pro to assemble the rendered sequences, refine the pacing and integrate sound.

I chose this combination because each application could support a different part of the production while allowing the project to progress from 3D animation to a completed film..

Production Considerations

One of the main challenges during planning was balancing the creative ambitions of the film with the practical requirements of producing it independently.

The project involved several technically demanding elements, including restrained character animation, background characters, a large urban environment and a building collapse.

I needed to consider which elements required detailed animation and which could be communicated more efficiently through camera composition, editing or post-production effects.

This was particularly important because I wanted the audience’s attention to remain focused on the relationship between the protagonist and his surroundings.

Adding more movement or visual complexity would not necessarily improve the communication of the concept.

By identifying the most important elements during pre-production, I aimed to establish a workflow that would allow me to prioritise character performance and storytelling while keeping the project manageable.

Reflection

Establishing a production workflow helped me approach the project with a clearer understanding of the different stages involved in creating an independent animated film.

One of the main considerations was ensuring that the creative decisions made during pre-production could realistically be developed through the available tools and techniques.

Although the workflow continued to evolve during production, these initial decisions provided a structure for organising the environments, animation, rendering and post-production.

The following chapter documents how these plans were translated into practical animation work, including the experiments, technical challenges and adjustments that influenced the development of the film.

Categories
Final Major Project

02 – Research & Concept Development

2.1 Research Approach

Before beginning the production of my FMP, I wanted to develop a better understanding of emotional desensitisation and how it relates to everyday behaviour.

My research focused on the relationship between repeated exposure to distressing information, emotional reactions and the continuation of everyday routines. I was particularly interested in how people can remain aware of suffering around them while becoming less visibly affected by it.

To investigate this, I combined theoretical research, visual references and an online questionnaire. Each approach served a different purpose within the development of my project.

The theoretical research helped me explore concepts such as repetition, normalisation, psychological distance and emotional self-protection. The questionnaire allowed me to examine how individuals interpret these experiences in their own lives, while visual research helped me consider how similar psychological subjects could be communicated through animation.

I chose this combination because I did not want to base the narrative entirely on my own assumptions about emotional desensitisation.

Instead, I wanted to use different perspectives to inform the character’s behaviour, the progression of events and the overall visual approach.

The main objective of this research was therefore not only to understand the subject, but also to identify which aspects could be translated into character animation and visual storytelling.

2.2 Audience Survey & Findings

As part of my research, I conducted an online questionnaire that received 34 responses. The survey included both open-ended and closed-ended questions exploring how participants understood emotional desensitisation and how they perceived their own reactions to distressing content.

When asked whether people are becoming less emotionally affected by distressing events they encounter regularly, 54.5% of participants agreed and 36.4% strongly agreed. Combined, this represents 90.9% of respondents, suggesting that the majority of participants perceived reduced emotional reactions to regularly encountered distressing events as a common experience.

However, I was particularly interested in the open-ended responses, as these provided more detailed explanations of why people might react differently to repeated exposure.

Several recurring themes emerged from the questionnaire, which influenced different aspects of my narrative and character development.

Repetition and Normalisation

One of the most common themes was the idea that repeated exposure can make disturbing situations feel increasingly familiar.

Several participants described how news, violence and other distressing experiences may gradually lose their initial emotional impact.

One participant explained:

“People getting used to seeing negative / shocking things, and it not shocking them anymore overtime – it becoming normalised.”

This response was particularly relevant to my project because it suggested that emotional desensitisation could be communicated through a contrast between extraordinary events and ordinary behaviour.

Rather than showing the protagonist becoming progressively more distressed, I decided to maintain a relatively consistent performance as the situations around him become more extreme.

The intention is to make the audience increasingly aware of the difference between the seriousness of the events and the character’s reactions.

Emotional Distance and Self-Protection

Another important finding was that emotional detachment does not necessarily mean a person lacks empathy.

Some participants suggested that distancing oneself emotionally can be a way of coping with the constant presence of distressing information.

One response particularly stood out:

“You wouldn’t be able to live if you had the same deep emotional reaction to every distressing event you encounter.”

This challenged the idea of presenting emotional desensitisation as something entirely negative or as a deliberate lack of concern for others.

As a result, I wanted to avoid portraying the protagonist as an intentionally cruel character.

Instead, I chose a more ambiguous representation in which his limited emotional responses could be interpreted as familiarity, detachment or a form of psychological adaptation.

This also influenced my approach to character animation. By avoiding exaggerated expressions of indifference, I wanted to leave room for the audience to interpret his behaviour rather than explicitly defining his emotional state.

Social Media and Continuous Exposure

Several participants mentioned social media as an environment where people frequently encounter distressing information alongside unrelated content.

One participant described the impact of continuously scrolling between different types of content:

“Because through scrolling, you forget what you were exposed to with the next video that evokes different emotions”

This response directly influenced my decision to incorporate phone scrolling into the opening sequence.

I was interested in how scrolling represents a repetitive action that allows information to be consumed and quickly replaced without requiring a sustained emotional response.

By placing this activity at the beginning of the film, I aim to establish the protagonist’s routine before introducing the events that unfold outside his bedroom.

The phone therefore functions as more than an everyday object. It represents the continuous flow of information and the ease with which attention can shift away from distressing situations.

Routine and Everyday Behaviour

Another recurring theme was the role of routine in shaping people’s responses to their surroundings.

When asked why individuals continue their everyday lives despite being aware of suffering and violence, several participants referred to adaptation, necessity and habitual behaviour.

One participant described this as:

“Probably because people just go on autopilot and stick to their routine.”

This response helped shape the protagonist’s behaviour throughout the film.

I wanted his actions to feel familiar and almost automatic, particularly when walking through the city.

Rather than stopping to investigate or respond to every situation, he continues moving through the environment.

This decision also supports the visual contrast within the narrative. While the surroundings become increasingly chaotic, the protagonist’s ordinary movements remain relatively unchanged.

Reflection on the Findings

The questionnaire helped me recognise that emotional desensitisation can be understood through several interconnected ideas rather than a single explanation.

Although the limited sample size does not allow me to draw conclusions about society as a whole, the responses provided useful perspectives for developing the narrative.

Most importantly, the findings influenced three specific creative decisions: maintaining a restrained character performance, using repetitive everyday actions and gradually increasing the severity of the surrounding events.

These decisions allow the film to explore emotional desensitisation through behaviour and visual contrast rather than through direct explanation.

The questionnaire therefore became an important connection between my initial research and the practical development of the animation.

2.3 Visual Research & Inspirations

Alongside my theoretical research and questionnaire, I explored how other animated films communicate complex psychological and emotional subjects.

I was particularly interested in how animation can represent experiences that are difficult to communicate through dialogue or realistic visual representation alone.

Two films that influenced my thinking were Waltz with Bashir (2008) and Inside Out (2015).

Although they approach their subjects very differently, both demonstrate how visual storytelling can make psychological experiences more accessible to an audience.

Waltz with Bashir (2008)

Waltz with Bashir, directed by Ari Folman, explores memory and trauma through animated documentary storytelling.

What interested me most was the relationship between its stylised visual representation and the seriousness of its subject matter.

The film demonstrates how animation can create a certain distance from disturbing events while still communicating their emotional significance.

This was particularly relevant to my research because I was interested in the difference between witnessing a distressing situation and visibly responding to it.

For my own project, this encouraged me to consider how the environment could communicate the seriousness of an event without requiring the protagonist to express an equally strong emotional reaction.

Rather than using facial expressions to explain how the audience should feel, I want to create situations in which the visual contrast itself becomes meaningful.

The main influence of Waltz with Bashir is therefore not its specific animation style, but its demonstration of how animation can approach difficult subjects through carefully considered visual representation.

Inside Out (2015)

Inside Out, directed by Pete Docter, approaches psychological storytelling differently by transforming emotions and internal mental processes into characters and environments.

I was particularly interested in how the film translates abstract experiences into visual elements that are understandable without requiring complex explanations.

This made me consider how emotional desensitisation, which is not always externally visible, could be represented through animation.

However, rather than showing emotions directly as Inside Out does, I decided to explore their apparent absence.

The protagonist’s restrained facial expressions and repetitive actions become meaningful when contrasted with the events around him.

This approach allows the audience to interpret his emotional state through his behaviour and surroundings rather than through a direct representation of his internal thoughts.

Influence on My Project

Although Waltz with Bashir and Inside Out use different storytelling techniques, both encouraged me to consider animation as a medium capable of communicating more than physical actions.

From Waltz with Bashir, I became interested in the relationship between stylisation, psychological distance and serious subject matter.

From Inside Out, I took inspiration from the possibility of translating an abstract psychological concept into a visual narrative.

For my project, I aim to apply these ideas through a more restrained approach.

Rather than representing emotional desensitisation through a literal visual metaphor or an exaggerated emotional performance, I want the relationship between character behaviour, environmental events and narrative timing to communicate the concept.

This research helped me establish a clearer visual direction before moving into the practical development of the film.

2.4 Concept Development

Following my initial research, I began exploring how the findings could be translated into a short animated narrative.

One of the main challenges was communicating emotional desensitisation without making the message too explicit.

I wanted the audience to recognise the contrast between the protagonist and his surroundings while still having the freedom to interpret the reasons behind his behaviour.

Developing the Narrative Structure

I decided to organise the narrative around a gradual escalation of events.

The film begins with a familiar situation in the protagonist’s bedroom before moving into an urban environment where he encounters increasingly distressing circumstances.

I chose situations involving homelessness and confrontation because they represent forms of suffering or conflict that people may encounter in everyday public spaces.

The later building collapse introduces a more extreme event that moves beyond an ordinary street encounter.

By increasing the scale of the situations, I aim to make the protagonist’s limited reactions progressively more noticeable.

This structure also creates a visual progression from familiar environments and relatively ordinary situations towards a more chaotic and unsettling atmosphere.

Developing the Ending

Another important decision was returning to the bedroom for the final sequence.

I wanted the narrative to end in the same familiar environment where it begins, creating a sense of repetition and continuity.

However, this time, the protagonist’s phone runs out of battery, interrupting his routine and producing a visible emotional reaction.

I chose this ending because it introduces a contrast between the protagonist’s responses to external suffering and his reaction to a relatively minor personal inconvenience.

The intention is not to suggest that the character is incapable of feeling emotions, but rather to question what determines which situations receive an emotional response.

By returning to the opening environment, the ending also connects the protagonist’s behaviour in the city with the routine established at the beginning of the film.

Balancing the Concept with Production Feasibility

While developing the narrative, I also needed to consider what could realistically be achieved within the scope of an independently produced animated film.

The project involves character animation, multiple environments, background activity and a large-scale environmental event.

I therefore began considering how camera composition, timing and environmental changes could communicate parts of the story without requiring complex character performances in every scene.

This was particularly relevant to the protagonist, whose restrained movements are not only central to the concept but also allow greater attention to be given to subtle details in his animation.

However, I remained aware that visually simple movements could still require significant refinement to appear natural and convincing.

These considerations helped me establish a narrative that balances the creative intentions of the project with its practical production requirements.

The next stage involves translating the concept into storyboards, shot planning, character preparation and the development of the 3D environments.

Categories
Final Major Project

01 — Introduction & Project Overview

1.1 Introduction

For my Final Major Project (FMP) as part of the MA 3D Computer Animation course at the University of the Arts London, I am developing a short, stylised 3D animated film exploring the concept of emotional desensitisation.

In contemporary society, people are constantly exposed to information through social media, news platforms and everyday interactions. Images of conflict, violence, poverty and human suffering frequently appear alongside ordinary entertainment and personal content.

I am particularly interested in the contrast between the seriousness of these events and the relatively limited emotional responses they sometimes receive. Situations that would normally be considered shocking can gradually become familiar when encountered repeatedly, raising questions about how constant exposure influences our perception of suffering.

Rather than approaching emotional desensitisation as a complete absence of empathy, I want to explore how routine, familiarity and psychological distance might influence the way people respond to events around them.

I am choosing animation as the medium for this investigation because it allows psychological experiences to be communicated through visual elements that are not always possible to express through realistic representation. Character performance, environmental changes, composition and timing can all contribute to communicating an emotional state without relying on explicit explanations.

This project therefore provides an opportunity to combine my interest in human behaviour with my developing skills in character animation and visual storytelling, while exploring how a psychological subject can be translated into a short animated narrative.

1.2 Project Concept

My project follows a young man who appears emotionally disconnected from the events happening around him.

The narrative begins in his bedroom, where he is lying in bed and scrolling through his phone. Outside, flashing emergency lights suggest that something serious may be happening nearby. However, the protagonist remains absorbed in his ordinary routine.

I choose to begin with this familiar activity because scrolling through social media has become such an automatic part of everyday life. The bedroom represents a private and comfortable environment in which information can be consumed without necessarily engaging with the situations being presented.

As the film progresses, the protagonist moves through an urban environment where he encounters increasingly distressing situations, including homelessness, confrontation and eventually the collapse of buildings.

I deliberately structure these events to become progressively more extreme. By gradually increasing the severity of the situations while maintaining the protagonist’s restrained reactions, I aim to create a growing contrast between what the audience witnesses and how the character responds.

The final sequence returns to the bedroom, where the protagonist reacts with visible frustration when his phone runs out of battery.

I choose this ending to reverse the emotional expectations established throughout the film. While the protagonist shows little reaction to events involving the suffering of others, a relatively minor inconvenience affecting his own routine produces a noticeable emotional response.

This contrast forms the central idea of the narrative. Rather than presenting the protagonist as deliberately cruel or uncaring, I want the audience to question how repeated exposure, familiarity and personal relevance might influence emotional reactions.

My intention is not to provide a definitive explanation of emotional desensitisation, but to create a situation that encourages viewers to reflect on their own responses to distressing information and everyday events.

1.3 Aims and Objectives

The primary aim of my Final Major Project is to investigate how emotional desensitisation can be represented through a short 3D animated film without relying on spoken dialogue.

I want to explore how character performance, visual contrast and environmental storytelling can communicate a psychological concept while allowing the audience to develop their own interpretation of the narrative.

My main creative and technical objectives are:

  • Visual storytelling: Develop a short narrative that communicates emotional detachment primarily through character behaviour, composition and the relationship between the protagonist and his surroundings.
  • Character animation: Explore restrained facial expressions, subtle body movements and repetitive actions to create a believable performance without exaggerated emotional reactions.
  • Narrative structure: Use a gradual escalation of external events to strengthen the contrast between the severity of the situations and the protagonist’s limited responses.
  • Cinematography and lighting: Experiment with camera composition, movement, colour and lighting to guide the audience’s attention and establish atmosphere.
  • Environmental storytelling: Develop contrasting interior and exterior environments that support the progression of the narrative.
  • Technical development: Strengthen my practical skills in Autodesk Maya, Arnold rendering and post-production techniques while managing the different stages of an independent animated production.
  • Critical reflection: Document my creative decisions, technical experiments and challenges throughout the project, evaluating how these influence the development of the final film.

An important part of these objectives is finding a balance between communicating the concept clearly and allowing room for interpretation. Because the narrative contains no dialogue, the timing of the animation and the relationship between different visual elements are particularly important.

1.4 Intended Outcome

The intended outcome of this project is a completed short, stylised 3D animated film that explores emotional desensitisation through character performance, cinematography and environmental storytelling.

The film combines two principal environments: a bedroom representing familiarity and routine, and an urban setting in which the protagonist encounters increasingly disturbing events.

I want these environments to function as more than backgrounds. Their differences in scale, atmosphere and activity help establish the contrast between the protagonist’s ordinary behaviour and the situations unfolding around him.

From an animation perspective, my priority is to develop a character performance in which the absence of strong reactions becomes meaningful. Rather than relying on dramatic expressions, I aim to use subtle movements, pauses and changes in timing to communicate the protagonist’s emotional distance.

The project also aims to challenge me technically by bringing together character animation, environmental design, lighting, rendering and post-production within a complete production workflow.

Alongside the film, this development blog documents the different stages of the project, from initial research and concept development to animation, technical experimentation and final evaluation.

Through this process, I aim to demonstrate not only the development of a completed animated film, but also how research, experimentation and creative decision-making influence its direction.

Ultimately, my goal is to create a visually engaging narrative that encourages viewers to consider how repeated exposure to suffering can affect emotional responses, and why events that directly interrupt our personal routines may sometimes provoke stronger reactions than more serious situations happening around us.