5.1 Arnold Rendering & Optimisation
Establishing the Rendering Workflow
After completing the main animation and lighting setups, I began preparing the scenes for rendering using Arnold in Autodesk Maya.
My main objective was to achieve consistent image quality across the different shots while keeping rendering times manageable.
This was particularly important because the film combines two environments with different lighting conditions, materials and levels of complexity.
I wanted to maintain enough visual detail for the characters and environments to appear convincing without introducing unnecessarily long rendering times.
Render Settings and Sampling
During the initial rendering tests, I experimented with Arnold’s sampling settings to find an appropriate balance between image quality and performance.
I initially used a Camera AA value of 5 before increasing it to 8 for the higher-quality renders.
I made this adjustment because some of the initial results contained visible noise, particularly in areas involving shadows, indirect lighting and more complex materials.
Increasing the sampling value helped produce cleaner images, although it also increased the time required to render each frame.
I also experimented with diffuse sampling and denoising to investigate how these settings influenced the final appearance.
One of the main challenges was determining whether the improvement in visual quality justified the additional rendering time.
Rather than simply increasing every setting, I began comparing individual test renders to identify which adjustments produced noticeable improvements.
This helped me understand that higher sampling values do not automatically represent the most efficient rendering solution.

Rendering Image Sequences
I rendered the animation as individual PNG image sequences rather than exporting directly to video.
Although this decision had already been established during pre-production, it became particularly useful during the rendering stage.
Some sequences required a large number of frames, meaning that interruptions or rendering errors could become costly.
Using image sequences allowed me to inspect individual frames and continue rendering from a specific point when necessary.
It also made it easier to identify visual problems before importing the sequences into Adobe Premiere Pro.
This approach provided greater control over the rendered output and reduced the risk of having to repeat an entire sequence because of a problem affecting only a few frames.
Render Times and Performance
Rendering became one of the most time-consuming stages of the project.
During one rendering session, a sequence of approximately 220 frames required around four hours to complete.
This made me more aware of the practical consequences of increasing render quality, particularly when working with longer sequences.
Even relatively small changes to materials, lighting or camera movements could require additional rendering.
I therefore began treating render time as an important production consideration rather than something to evaluate only after completing the animation.
Before starting longer renders, I checked the camera framing, animation timing and lighting to reduce the likelihood of discovering major problems afterwards.
Although this did not eliminate every issue, it helped me approach the rendering process more carefully.
Testing and Quality Control
Before committing to complete image sequences, I used individual test renders to evaluate the appearance of different shots.
I checked lighting, shadows, material reflections, character visibility and overall composition.
This was especially important because certain assets appeared differently in Arnold compared with Maya’s viewport.
I also reviewed rendered frames to identify problems that might not have been obvious during animation.
One important consideration was ensuring that the visual quality remained consistent between the bedroom and exterior sequences despite their different lighting setups.
These tests helped me identify which elements required additional adjustments before committing to longer rendering sessions.
Reflection
Working with Arnold made me more aware of the relationship between visual quality, scene complexity and rendering efficiency.
The most useful lesson was learning to evaluate rendering settings according to their actual visual impact rather than assuming that higher values would always produce a better result.
This encouraged me to use test renders more deliberately and to consider the cost of making late changes.
As a result, rendering became an important part of my decision-making process rather than simply the final technical step after animation.
5.2 Materials & Texture Refinement
Working with Imported Materials
Throughout production, I encountered several inconsistencies in the materials and textures of imported 3D assets.
Because the environments and characters originated from different sources, their shaders did not always respond consistently to the lighting setups.
Some surfaces appeared excessively reflective, while others displayed incorrect colours or required adjustments to their transparency.
I used Maya’s Hypershade and Attribute Editor to investigate the relevant material properties and texture connections.
Rather than modifying the entire visual style of the scene, I focused on correcting individual assets that appeared noticeably inconsistent with their surroundings.
Adjusting Excessively Glossy Materials
One of the most noticeable issues involved the background characters and certain objects in the city environment.
Several imported materials appeared unusually glossy, creating strong reflections and highlights that did not suit the intended visual appearance.
This was particularly noticeable on some of the background characters, where clothing and body surfaces appeared almost plastic-like.
To investigate the problem, I examined the shader properties, including specular colour, reflectivity and related material settings.
I experimented with reducing unwanted reflections to create a more balanced appearance.
I also encountered similar problems with environmental objects, including streetlights, where certain surfaces remained reflective even after initial adjustments.
These issues required me to inspect the relevant materials individually rather than assuming that changing one setting would correct the entire object.
The adjustments helped reduce distracting highlights and improve the visual consistency of the exterior scenes.


Refining Traffic Light Materials
Another issue involved the traffic lights within the city environment.
Initially, some of the traffic light surfaces appeared almost black, even when they were intended to display an illuminated colour.
This made them difficult to recognise within the rendered scene.
I investigated the connected materials and experimented with emission settings to make the coloured surfaces more visible.
For example, I adjusted the green traffic light material to an emission value of approximately 5.
This made the illuminated section more recognisable without requiring additional external lighting.
I later experimented with similar adjustments for red traffic lights.
This was a relatively small modification compared with the larger animation tasks, but it improved the readability of the urban environment.

Maintaining Visual Consistency
As I continued testing materials, I realised that an object could appear acceptable in isolation but noticeably different when placed alongside other assets.
I therefore began evaluating materials within their actual lighting environments rather than relying entirely on the viewport.
This was particularly important for the city, where the combination of imported shaders and exterior lighting sometimes produced unexpected results.
Some material problems required repeated adjustments because changing the reflective properties of a surface could also influence its overall appearance.
I needed to find a balance between reducing unwanted highlights and preserving enough shading information for the objects to remain visually convincing.
Reflection
Refining the imported materials required more technical investigation than I initially expected.
Although the changes were often relatively small, they could noticeably affect the overall appearance of the rendered environment.
This process encouraged me to examine shader properties and texture connections more systematically instead of relying only on visual adjustments.
It also demonstrated that working with existing assets does not necessarily eliminate the need for material development and troubleshooting.
5.3 Compositing in After Effects
Exploring Dust and Atmospheric Effects
After developing the building collapse in Maya, I began investigating how to introduce dust into the sequence.
I wanted the collapse to feel larger and more destructive, with dust spreading across the environment and partially obscuring the scene.
One of my main concerns was achieving a convincing sense of volume and depth.
Because the building collapses towards the right side of the composition, I also wanted the dust to feel connected to that location rather than appearing as an unrelated effect covering the screen.
I initially explored compositing techniques in Adobe After Effects, using dust footage as a separate visual layer.
However, the first experiments did not fully produce the heavy, three-dimensional appearance I wanted.

Experimenting with Unreal Engine Niagara
To investigate an alternative approach, I experimented with Unreal Engine’s Niagara particle system.
I tested a dust explosion effect to explore whether a particle-based simulation could offer more control over the appearance and movement of the dust.
I experimented with the size and positioning of the effect and examined how the particles behaved within the 3D environment.
One difficulty involved positioning the simulation so that it appeared correctly from the intended camera angle.
Although the effect was visible, the results did not fully match the dense dust cloud I had imagined.
I also found that integrating a separate Unreal Engine effect into my existing Maya and After Effects workflow introduced additional complexity.
I therefore had to evaluate whether continuing to develop a complete particle simulation was practical within the remaining production time.
This experiment was useful because it allowed me to compare the flexibility of a particle-based system with the more accessible approach of compositing existing footage.

Evaluating External VFX Assets
Following the Niagara experiments, I began researching existing dust effects that could be adapted to the sequence.
I explored different stock footage and pre-made effects, comparing their density, direction and visual appearance.
One of the main difficulties was finding footage that matched the scale and movement of the building collapse.
Some effects appeared too light or transparent, while others moved in directions that did not correspond with the composition.
I was particularly interested in footage containing a dense cloud of dust that could gradually occupy a larger area of the frame.
Using existing footage offered a more manageable alternative to creating a complete particle simulation from scratch.
However, it also meant accepting certain limitations in perspective and the amount of control available over the movement.


Blending and Layer Integration
After importing dust footage into After Effects, I experimented with blending modes and layer settings to integrate it with the rendered animation.
Because the footage existed as a separate layer, I needed to consider how its background, colour and transparency interacted with the underlying scene.
I wanted to avoid an effect that looked obviously placed on top of the animation.
I therefore tested different blending approaches and examined how the dust appeared against the buildings and surrounding environment.
This helped me identify the limitations of the footage and determine which adjustments could improve its integration.
Adjusting Scale, Density and Movement
Another challenge was creating the impression of a sufficiently large dust cloud.
Some of the footage I tested appeared too transparent, particularly when placed over the exterior environment.
I experimented with increasing its scale and adjusting its visibility to create a heavier appearance.
However, enlarging the footage sometimes made the effect look flatter and less connected to the perspective of the scene.
I also explored directional movement because I wanted the dust to feel as though it originated from the collapsing buildings rather than expanding uniformly.
These experiments highlighted the difficulty of representing a three-dimensional atmospheric event through two-dimensional footage.


Experimenting with Timing and Transitions
As I continued developing the effect, I also explored how the dust could contribute to the transition between shots.
I experimented with reversing and extending the footage to change the direction and timing of its movement.
I also adjusted opacity to create a gradual fade rather than allowing the dust to disappear abruptly.
This was particularly important because the effect needed to remain connected to the timing of the building collapse.
I considered how the dust could temporarily obscure the environment before gradually disappearing or transitioning into the following sequence.
Although the experiments did not provide the same control as a complete 3D simulation, they allowed me to explore how compositing and editing could work together to create a more continuous visual sequence.
Reflection
The dust experiments became an important example of balancing visual ambition with technical feasibility.
I initially wanted a dense, three-dimensional effect, but creating and integrating this proved more complicated than expected.
Comparing After Effects, Niagara and existing VFX footage helped me evaluate the advantages and limitations of different approaches.
The main difficulty was not simply creating visible dust, but making the effect appear connected to the camera perspective, surrounding environment and timing of the collapse.
This process gave me a better understanding of how environmental effects need to be considered within the complete composition rather than developed in isolation.
5.4 Editing & Sound Design
Assembling the Film in Premiere Pro
After rendering the animated sequences, I began assembling the film in Adobe Premiere Pro.
I imported the PNG image sequences from Maya and arranged the different shots on the timeline.
One of the first technical issues I encountered involved the frame rate.
Although the animation was created at 24 frames per second, Premiere Pro initially interpreted some imported image sequences at 25 fps.
This created a potential inconsistency between the original animation timing and the editing timeline.
I therefore checked the footage interpretation and sequence settings to maintain a consistent frame rate of 24 fps.
This was important because even a small difference in playback speed could influence the timing of character movements and camera animation.
Refining the Pacing
One of the biggest challenges during editing was evaluating how the individual shots worked together.
While certain animations appeared effective when viewed separately in Maya, their timing sometimes felt different once they were assembled into a continuous sequence.
For example, some shots moved too quickly for the audience to observe both the protagonist and the surrounding events.
This was particularly important because the protagonist’s restrained reactions require time to become noticeable.
I therefore experimented with extending several sequences and adjusting the overall rhythm of the film.
In some cases, these changes required returning to Maya to extend camera movements or character animations before rendering additional frames.
Although this added work to the production process, it allowed me to make decisions based on how the film functioned as a complete narrative rather than judging each shot independently.
The editing process therefore became an important part of refining the animation itself.
Exploring Music and Atmosphere
Because the film contains no spoken dialogue, I also began exploring how music and sound could contribute to the emotional atmosphere.
I was particularly interested in using changes in sound intensity to support the progression of the narrative.
One idea involved gradually introducing a more chaotic soundscape as the protagonist encounters increasingly disturbing events in the city.
In contrast, I considered using a sudden change in atmosphere when the narrative returns to the bedroom.
I wanted the sound to reinforce the difference between the external environment and the protagonist’s personal routine without directly explaining his emotional state.
This required considering how music could support the visual storytelling rather than dominate it.
Sound Effects and Environmental Detail
I also explored how environmental sounds could help establish the different locations and events.
For the bedroom, I considered subtle ambient sounds that could reinforce the relatively quiet atmosphere.
The urban sequences offered opportunities to introduce traffic, pedestrian activity and other environmental sounds.
The confrontation and building collapse also presented opportunities for more intense audio.
I wanted to avoid creating a soundtrack that remained constantly loud or chaotic, as this could reduce the impact of the more dramatic moments.
Instead, I was interested in how changes in volume, intensity and silence could influence the audience’s experience.
In particular, the contrast between the destruction taking place outside and the protagonist’s ordinary routine offered an opportunity to use sound as an additional storytelling element.
Reflection
Editing the rendered sequences helped me identify pacing problems that were difficult to recognise while working on individual shots in Maya.
I realised that a technically successful animation does not automatically produce an effective sequence when placed alongside other shots.
The editing process required me to reconsider the duration of certain movements and how the audience’s attention shifted throughout the narrative.
It also encouraged me to treat sound as part of the film’s storytelling rather than simply as an additional element introduced after the visual work.
5.5 Final Rendering Challenges & Reflection
Managing Software Instability
One of the most significant challenges during the later stages of production was the instability of Autodesk Maya.
As the project became more complex, I experienced unexpected crashes and slower performance, particularly when working with detailed environments and demanding scene configurations.
This was frustrating because certain problems occurred while I was making adjustments to scenes that were already close to completion.
I also accessed Maya through Omnissa Horizon for parts of the production, meaning that my workflow depended on both the software and the stability of the remote connection.
This sometimes made it more difficult to work efficiently, particularly when switching between scene adjustments, animation and rendering tests.
As a result, I became more cautious about making major changes to complex scenes and placed greater importance on maintaining recoverable versions.
Managing Late-Stage Changes
Another challenge was deciding how to approach adjustments after sequences had already been rendered.
During editing, I continued identifying opportunities to improve shot timing, camera movement and visual consistency.
However, even relatively small changes could require additional rendering.
This meant considering whether a modification would produce a noticeable improvement or introduce unnecessary risks and production time.
I began prioritising adjustments that directly affected the readability and pacing of the film.
For example, extending a shot could be more important than refining a minor background detail if it allowed the audience to understand the narrative more clearly.
This required a different approach from the earlier stages of production, where I had more flexibility to experiment with individual elements.
File Management and Recovery
Managing project files also became increasingly important as production progressed.
Working with multiple Maya scenes, textures, imported assets and rendered image sequences resulted in a large number of files and different versions.
At one point, I encountered a situation where a Maya scene appeared to be missing.
Fortunately, I was able to recover the file, but the experience made me more aware of the importance of maintaining backups.
Working across different computers and using cloud synchronisation also required additional attention to file locations and accessibility.
I needed to ensure that the correct versions of scenes and supporting assets were available when continuing work.
This experience demonstrated how file management could directly influence production efficiency, particularly when dealing with large and technically demanding projects.
Learning to Prioritise
As the film approached completion, I became increasingly aware that not every technical or visual issue could receive the same amount of attention.
Throughout production, I had sometimes spent considerable time attempting to refine relatively minor details.
Although this helped me develop my technical skills, I also began recognising that some adjustments had a greater impact on the final film than others.
I therefore started evaluating changes according to their contribution to the narrative and overall visual quality.
This was especially important when deciding whether to repeat a render, extend an animation or continue experimenting with a visual effect.
Rather than attempting to perfect every individual element, I began focusing more on the consistency and effectiveness of the film as a whole.
Reflection
The final production stage required me to balance technical refinement with the practical limitations of completing an independent animated film.
One of the main lessons was learning to recognise when additional experimentation was useful and when it risked delaying more important work.
The combination of software instability, rendering requirements, file management and late-stage adjustments encouraged me to develop a more organised and selective approach to production.
Although not every visual or technical element reached the level of refinement I initially imagined, these experiences helped me understand the importance of making decisions within the context of the complete project.
The most valuable outcome was developing a more realistic understanding of how creative ambition, technical limitations and production time influence one another when bringing an animated film towards completion.