Categories
Final Major Project

06 — Final Outcome, Evaluation & Reflection

6.1 Final Film & Presentation

The final stage of my Final Major Project focused on bringing the individual elements of production together into a complete short animated film.

After several stages of research, pre-production, animation, rendering and post-production, I began evaluating the project as a continuous narrative rather than a collection of individual shots.

The completed sequences follow the protagonist, The Observer, as he moves between his familiar bedroom environment and an increasingly disturbing urban setting.

One of my main objectives was to communicate emotional desensitisation without relying on spoken dialogue. Instead, I used character performance, visual contrast, camera composition and changes in the surrounding environment to communicate the narrative.

A particularly important element was the relationship between the severity of the events and the protagonist’s restrained reactions.

As the situations become more extreme, his behaviour remains relatively unchanged. This contrast is intended to make the audience question why certain events appear to have so little emotional impact on him.

The final bedroom sequence introduces a different response when the protagonist becomes frustrated after his phone runs out of battery.

I wanted this moment to challenge the expectations established throughout the film and emphasise the difference between his reactions to external suffering and a minor inconvenience affecting his personal routine.

Looking at the film as a whole also made me more aware of how individual creative and technical decisions affected the final narrative. Elements such as the duration of shots, the subtlety of facial expressions and the transition between environments became particularly important when evaluating whether the scenes worked together.

Although I cannot determine how every viewer will interpret the film without audience testing, I believe the final sequence provides a visual foundation for exploring the emotional contradiction at the centre of my research.

6.2 Critical Reflection & Personal Development

Looking back at my Final Major Project, I feel proud of what I have managed to achieve, particularly when considering my level of experience at the beginning of the course.

Before starting my MA in 3D Computer Animation, I had never worked with software such as Maya, Blender or Unreal Engine. Entering a completely unfamiliar field was challenging, especially because I tend to set very high expectations for myself and often have ideas that are more ambitious than my current technical abilities allow.

Throughout this project, one of my biggest challenges was accepting that the final result would not always match what I had originally imagined. I often had a very specific visual outcome in mind, but translating those ideas into three-dimensional animation required knowledge and experience that I was still developing.

This became particularly apparent during the more technically demanding sequences, such as the building collapse, environmental effects and certain character animations. Although I knew what I wanted these moments to look like, achieving that result was not always straightforward.

For example, when developing the building collapse sequence, I wanted the dust to gradually fill the environment and create a convincing transition between shots. I experimented with different approaches in After Effects and Unreal Engine, but achieving the density, depth and movement I imagined proved more complicated than expected. This made me realise how important it is to consider the technical requirements of an effect before incorporating it into a project.

However, I also recognise how much I have learned through these difficulties.

A significant part of my development came from independently researching solutions whenever I encountered a problem. I frequently consulted online tutorials, technical documentation, community discussions and AI-assisted tools such as ChatGPT to help me investigate unfamiliar techniques, understand errors and explore different approaches.

Rather than following a single established workflow, I often had to experiment, test possible solutions and adapt them to my own scenes. This was particularly important when working with complex character rigs, animation curves, Python scripts, lighting and rendering issues.

One example was the use of Python scripting in Maya. As my scenes became more complex, I began using scripts to inspect animation data, modify keyframes and extend character movements. This was particularly useful when adjusting the walking sequences, where maintaining consistent movement across different shots required repeated changes to controller positions and animation timing.

Although I did not always fully understand every technical issue immediately, working through these problems gradually made me more comfortable investigating how different parts of Maya functioned.

Another important lesson was understanding the relationship between creative ambition and technical feasibility.

I naturally tend to develop ambitious ideas, sometimes without fully considering how difficult they may be to execute. While I still consider this ambition an important part of my creativity, the project taught me that having a strong idea is only one part of the production process.

A clear example of this was the final bedroom sequence. I initially planned for the protagonist to throw his phone in frustration after discovering that the battery had died. However, creating a convincing interaction between the hand and the phone introduced several technical difficulties involving object constraints, positioning and animation.

After experimenting with different solutions, I eventually decided to remove the action and focus on communicating his frustration through facial animation instead.

Although this was not my original intention, it helped me understand that simplifying an idea does not necessarily mean losing its meaning. In this case, the more restrained reaction also remained consistent with the character’s overall performance.

I also became more aware of my own limitations as an animator. There are still aspects of the final film that I would like to improve, particularly the naturalness of certain character movements, the quality of the visual effects and the overall refinement of some sequences.

The walking animations, for example, required more adjustments than I had initially expected. Maintaining consistent movement while avoiding issues such as foot sliding or unnatural body positioning was particularly challenging.

These difficulties highlighted the importance of understanding body mechanics and movement rather than focusing only on achieving the correct position or timing.

I do not consider myself an advanced animator, and I know that I still have a great deal to learn. However, I also think it is important to recognise the progress I have made over a relatively short period.

Perhaps the most valuable lesson has been learning to balance my expectations with my experience. I still set high standards for myself, and I do not always feel completely satisfied when a result differs from what I originally imagined. However, I am beginning to understand that these differences are part of the learning process rather than simply signs of failure.

Ultimately, this project has helped me develop not only technical skills, but also greater patience, adaptability and confidence in my ability to learn unfamiliar tools.

While the final film may not fully reflect every detail of my original vision, it represents the knowledge, experimentation and problem-solving that I have developed throughout these past months. That is something I am genuinely proud of.

6.3 Future Improvements & Conclusion

Improving Pre-Production

If I were to approach a similar project again, one of the main changes I would make would be to develop a more detailed animatic before beginning character animation.

Although I created storyboards and planned the general sequence of events, I underestimated how much the timing of individual shots would influence the production process.

Several sequences needed to be extended after they had already been animated, which also required adjustments to character movement, camera animation and rendering.

For example, I extended the opening bedroom camera movement to give the audience more time to establish the environment and observe the protagonist’s routine.

Testing the full narrative earlier would have allowed me to identify these pacing problems before committing to more detailed production work.

Testing Technical Elements Earlier

Another improvement would be to test technically demanding elements before incorporating them into the main production.

The building collapse and dust effects demonstrated how a relatively short moment in the final film could require considerable experimentation.

In future projects, I would create smaller technical tests to determine whether an effect could be achieved with the available software, skills and production resources before developing the complete scene.

I would also establish a clearer system for saving scene versions and organising assets, particularly when working with large environments.

Developing My Animation and VFX Skills

From a technical perspective, I would like to continue developing my character animation skills, particularly in body mechanics, weight distribution and natural movement.

I would also like to explore facial animation and secondary movements in greater depth, as I became increasingly interested in how subtle changes in performance can communicate a character’s emotional state.

Another area I want to develop further is environmental effects and compositing. My experiments during this project introduced me to several techniques that I would like to understand more thoroughly, particularly the integration of atmospheric effects into three-dimensional scenes.

Incorporating Audience Feedback

Finally, I would introduce audience testing earlier in the development process.

Because The Observer relies on visual interpretation rather than spoken dialogue, feedback from viewers unfamiliar with my research would be particularly valuable.

I would be interested in understanding whether audiences recognise the contrast between the protagonist’s behaviour and his surroundings, and whether the final scene communicates the intended emotional contradiction.

This would allow me to evaluate the clarity of the narrative beyond my own interpretation.

Final Reflection

My Final Major Project has been an important opportunity to bring together the creative and technical skills I have developed throughout my MA in 3D Computer Animation.

What began as an investigation into emotional desensitisation developed into an independent production that challenged both my creative ambitions and technical abilities.

Although the process did not always progress as planned, it taught me that adapting an idea is just as important as developing it.

I still have many areas in which I want to improve, but completing this project has given me a better understanding of the animation production process and the skills required to translate an idea into a finished film.

Most importantly, it has shown me how much I can learn by challenging myself, experimenting with unfamiliar techniques and continuing to work through difficulties even when the outcome is uncertain.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *